Take the 2-minute tour ×
History Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for historians and history buffs. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Urban renewal projects defined by Wikipedia as "a program of land redevelopment in areas of moderate to high density urban land use" started in the 19th century with two very different rationales. In London, they were motivated by a concern for public health and in Paris, they were motivated by a concern for the aesthetics of the city. Today it seems that urban renewal projects can have many disparate motivations, although all share a post-modern and capitalist logic in my opinion: road construction, removing urban blight, increasing tourism, historical preservation, promoting mixed development and more efficient use of city spaces, promoting ethnic integration, increasing the tax base or economic development, etc. (Feel free to argue that this makes no sense. I'm not sure it has any "logic")

I would like to know if the historical development of urban renewal has been roughly similar internationally in the 20th century or if in some parts of the world it has been commonly used for different reasons in some places than in other places?

If it has been different, what might be the reasons? I am wondering if the reasons might be to address more practical concerns or if they are more commonly due to the cultural differences, the differences in popularity of art movements or ideology (ideology-fascism, capitalism, communism- can strongly influence art and building choice).

share|improve this question
    
You might be interested in David Harvey short text "a right to the city": davidharvey.org/media/righttothecity.pdf He touches a few questions of how and why urban renewal was done (though I'm not sure he directly answers your question) –  mart May 12 at 6:48

1 Answer 1

up vote 2 down vote accepted

Having done some research on Urban Renewal, it seems that is a phenomenon that occurs for the same reasons in African and Asian nations as it does in Western nations - in that it occurs when it needs to in order for an area of a city to be rebuilt or repurposed. One of the best papers I found concerning Urban Renewal is "Neighborhood Regeneration in Beijing" on the McGill University School of Architecture website.

Experts present at the first International Seminar on Urban Renewal, held in Den Haag in August 1958, agreed that the main purpose of urban renewal is to deliberately change the urban environment and to inject new vitality through planned adjustment of existing areas to respond to present and future requirements for urban living and working (Miller, 1959).

"Neighborhood Regeneration in Beijing" - McGill University

As you quite rightly mentioned, in the late 19th century London was the focus of one of the first instances of state involvement in Urban Renewal (previously it was a process that was privately initiated, a notable example being during the industrial revolution) in order to combat the unhealthy living conditions in working class neighborhoods. (As an unrelated side note, the Boer War illustrated to the British Government that there was a serious issue with public health in some areas as "in some towns as many as nine out of ten recruits for the army were rejected because they were so unfit" - BBC).

This principle of urban renewal, public health and safety, can be seen as a driving force behind the process of urban renewal in Hong Kong that took place in 1954. The renewal of the Shek Kip Mei district was initiated by Governor Alexander Grantham after a huge fire in a slum saw some 53,000 people become homeless in 1953. As a result the Shek Kip Mei Low-cost Housing Estate was constructed.

The urban renewal that took place in Singapore in the 1960's was also as a slum clearance measure as some 25% of the cities then population was thought to be living in as little as 1% of the available land. This was a result of the huge amount of damage done during WW2.

The importance of both world wars in terms of urban renewal cannot also be understated. Huge amounts of damage were done to cities across Europe as well as cities in China, Japan and northern African nations.

Rather than write my own summary, the following quote from "Neighborhood Regeneration in Beijing" seems to fit perfectly with what I have found so far, and with what I was taught when studying Urban Geography while at college.

In summary, it can be observed that, both in developing and developed countries, the evolution of policies regarding urban renewal followed a similar pattern, gradually evolving from a demolition and reconstruction approach to a softer, more socially-oriented approach, which concentrates on the renovation of existing structures. The following section summarizes the possible approaches to urban renewal in residential areas, based on this brief review of urban renewal policies around the world.

"Neighborhood Regeneration in Beijing" - McGill University

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.