Take the 2-minute tour ×
History Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for historians and history buffs. It's 100% free, no registration required.

This site asserts that syphilis, polio, hepatitis, and encephalitis come to general world from the Americas but I am unable to prove that statement could someone confirm or deny it?

share|improve this question
    
This is related to this question - history.stackexchange.com/questions/1353/new-world-sickness/… maybe it will help –  MichaelF Aug 25 at 12:51

2 Answers 2

Hepatitis and encephalitis describe an inflammation of a specific organ (respectively the liver and the brain), not a specific virus or infectious agent, and can have multiple causes. Like many other infectious agents, the hepatitis viruses have been identified and described rather recently and early accounts are sometimes vague on the symptoms, thus making it difficult to identify a specific disease. I don't know if there are clear accounts of hepatitis infection in historical sources.

Polio is definitely considered to have been present in the old world in pre-Columbian times, possibly on account of its rather specific symptoms. It somewhat paradoxically became a bigger problem much later, with the progress of hygiene, which might account for the confusion.

Syphilis is the most interesting case. It has long been thought that it originated in the Americas and spread to Europe in the sixteenth Century (there is no evidence of large scale epidemics before that time) but new evidence called this into question. Potential confusion with leprosy, nonvenereal endemic syphilis (bejel) and yaws further complicate the interpretation of historical sources. There is some archeological evidence of a disease similar to syphilis in the old world, all the way back to Antiquity (specifically: bone damage in infants born to an infected mother) but such cases are in any case much rarer in Europe than in the Americas and whether this is actually the same disease is still debated. (I found a useful summary of the debate with various reputable sources on Wikipedia but unfortunately only in the French-language version of the website).

share|improve this answer
    
Re: "Hepatitis and encephalitis describe an infection of a specific organ": Not necessarily. Hepatitis really means inflammation of the liver. Aside from infection, other possible causes include various toxins and various autoimmune diseases; and conversely, not every liver infection necessarily causes hepatitis. Encephalitis, for its part, means acute inflammation of the brain. –  ruakh Aug 24 at 18:35
1  
A recent(-ish) phylogenetic study of Treponematoses suggests that syphilis originated from the closely related disease Yaws in central America and was transmitted to Europe around the time of Columbus. Central American Yaws seems, in turn, to have originated much earlier in Old World Yaws, which in one form or another probably evolved with us as we evolved from our ancestral species. plosntds.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pntd.0000148 –  Dan Sheppard Aug 25 at 0:40
    
@rukah Yes, indeed, poor choice of word. That's also what I meant by “multiple causes”. I edited the answer to correct that. –  Relaxed Aug 25 at 7:58

Syphilis has been in the America's for awhile, so far no evidence has been found of in pre-colombian Europe. Excerpt:

"Using these criteria, they examined 687 skeletons from archaeological sites in the United States and Ecuador ranging in age from 400 to 6,000 years. Populations to the south (New Mexico, Florida, and Ecuador) proved to have syphilis, while those to the north (Ohio, Illinois, and Virginia) had yaws. By contrast, examination of 1,000 Old World skeletons dated to before contact with the New World revealed no cases of syphilis."

Polio has been around for awhile, see wikipedia.
In terms of age,Hepatitis B is really old,as is the A variety, found in antiquity, Hep C seems to be a relatively recent epidemic, spread by the increased use of blood sharing medical instruments, and substance abuse.
Encephalitis is a catchall term for a variety of ailments found in Europe, Asia, and America.

I imagine that, like many animal species, these viruses have new and old world versions, brought to the Americas with migration of humans, and other primates, mammals,etc. Much in the same way that many North American species originated from Asia, such as Black Bears and Asian Black bears share genetic heritage.

Other notable examples: European Lyme vs. American Lyme (both spirochetes), Wisent Vs. American Bison Vs. Asian Water Buffalo.

Note that this is the same realm of suspect archeological territory, as the findings of Tobacco, Cocaine, and Cannabis in Ancient Egypt, or finding really old Chinese Ships sunken in the Sacramento Delta. Basically, the world has been interconnected longer than most American's and Europeans would care to admit.

share|improve this answer
    
Thanks thats sorda what i thought –  caseyr547 Aug 24 at 7:04
3  
"Try searching Google Scholar, or Books, you'll find tons of useful info." Well, in principle they might, certainly... and yet I am not sure the piece of advice is that useful. –  Did Aug 24 at 8:29

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.