According to Dr. Richard R. Muller in his December 2003 article in Air and Space Power entitled Losing Air Superiority: A Case Study from World War II, he argues that the Germans had definitively lost air superiority over Europe in fall of 1944. Here he describes the final hope of the Luftewaffe to regain control of the skies, and the unlikely nature of such a proposition to succeed,
Another proposal that has attracted postwar attention was Galland’s
suggestion to mass some 2,000–3,000 German fighters for a knockout
blow. His goal was to commit this force against an American bomber
formation in order to “shoot down an approximate total of 400–500
four-engined bombers against a loss of about 400 aircraft and about
100–150 pilots.”5 A victory on this scale would cause the Americans to
cease daylight penetrations, restoring air superiority at a single
stroke. In Galland’s view, Hitler scuttled this potentially decisive
action by earmarking his carefully husbanded fighter reserve for
support of the Ardennes counteroffensive in December 1944.
One has reasons to doubt the potential effectiveness of the “Great
Blow.” While the operation was in the planning stages, considerable
portions of the fighter reserve engaged American formations, but even
under favorable conditions, the Germans did not down a significant
number of American aircraft.6 The standards of German fighter-pilot
training were so low by fall 1944 that the bulk of the 2,000+ pilots
participating in the proposed operation would have been incapable of
operating effectively. In particular, the task of assembling and
controlling such a large quantity of aircraft in a single operation
was probably beyond the Luftwaffe’s capability in late 1944.