2,219 reputation
11137
bio website claimid.com/louisr
location Your computer
age 34
visits member for 2 years, 11 months
seen 2 days ago

trying to learn and help others learn :)


Sep
23
revised Does History confirm that prosperity, capitalism, and some form “democracy” or representative republican form of government always go hand in hand?
added 1160 characters in body
Sep
23
comment Why did Britain and France not declare war against the Soviet Union when it invaded Poland in WW2?
@Anixx, yeah, but the support and assistance has to come at once
Sep
23
comment Why didn't the Persians make and use ballistas and other kinds of artillery?
For example, you seem to imply that the Persian culture has different attitude towards big man studying mathematics (compared to the Greeks or the Romans), if this is true, can you support this by explanation or reference? Also, can you elaborate on "I suspect that the Persians simply didn't expend enough effort in peacetime to build the necessary infrastructure"?
Sep
23
comment Does History confirm that prosperity, capitalism, and some form “democracy” or representative republican form of government always go hand in hand?
@Vector good points, 1) listing several examples doesn't prove that it is the trend, and 2) modern democracies haven't been around too long. I'll try to address that in the answer
Sep
23
comment Why didn't the Persians make and use ballistas and other kinds of artillery?
In addition to the lack of source, it's the last paragraph (which you admit is the weakest one) that make your answer relevant to the question. Otherwise, it is just general observations and unsupported analysis about how artillery corps work.
Sep
22
answered Does History confirm that prosperity, capitalism, and some form “democracy” or representative republican form of government always go hand in hand?
Sep
12
comment Are Shi’i imams really directly related to the Prophet Muhammad?
@LennartRegebro but most probably it's Shia believer who wrote that article. And probably based on Shia Islamic tradition rather than history
Sep
12
comment Are Shi’i imams really directly related to the Prophet Muhammad?
@LennartRegebro one person can potentially have 2^40 40-generation ancestors, but I'm not sure how much this number is reduced by cousin marriages and stuff
Sep
12
comment Are Shi’i imams really directly related to the Prophet Muhammad?
I think this is on-topic, and after @LennartRegebro edit it doesn't look "judging" anymore
Sep
8
comment Historical causes of the civil wars in Lebanon, Iraq, and Syria?
one of the arguments I heard a lot is that the present Middle Eastern countries and borders were defined rather arbitrarily by the Europeans without any sensitivities to the existing identities, such as ethnics, tribes and religions which already exist. Previously there were no notions of Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Israel or Jordan, these "nations" were kind of forced by the arbitrarily-defined borders.
Sep
1
comment Which nation on Earth has been under foreign rule the longest?
England has been ruled by monarchs with Danish, French, Scottish and German origin (including the present dynasty)
Aug
29
comment What is “discovery” in the historical sense? How do historians today view and describe “discoveries”?
Columbus wasn't even the first European to visit the Americas, see @T.E.D. answer here
Aug
29
comment What happened to Israel when Persia attacked Egypt?
for example you can search "History of Israel" and see what happens at 525 BC.
Aug
28
comment What happened to Israel when Persia attacked Egypt?
because they can be answered by looking up relevant topics on Wikipedia or Google.
Aug
28
comment How was Abd al-Rahman I recognized when he arrived in Islamic Spain?
@Kobunite I was referring to the version before your edit, with bad grammar, punctuation and capitalization. Now it doesn't look so bad.
Aug
28
comment How was Abd al-Rahman I recognized when he arrived in Islamic Spain?
@FelixGoldberg: aside from the poor copyediting, there is no reference and it does not adequately explain why having a mother from tribe Nafra help the son to be recognized in Morocco and Spain.
Aug
27
revised What happened to Israel when Persia attacked Egypt?
added 235 characters in body
Aug
27
comment What happened to Israel when Persia attacked Egypt?
Search "Kingdom of Israel" in wikipedia, you will see that there is none at 525 BC. Click on the most recent one that preceded 525 BC, Kingdom of Judah 931–586 BCE, you will find what happened at the end
Aug
27
answered What happened to Israel when Persia attacked Egypt?
Aug
25
revised Were scientists in Ancient Egypt Egyptian, or were they from other regions?
tried to cut down on the blue and bold