5 add a link
source | link

why didn't America join the war after it sank?

Because, according to the Constitution (Article 1 Section 8), war is declared by Congress, and Congress was heavily isolationist.

Also, for all practical purposes, US was already at war:

When Hitler declared war on the US, he mentioned that "they are already fighting us anyway".

Constraints on FDR

As an extended reply to a comment

why didn't the President declare military action, based on the attack of one of their ships, (forcing Congress to go to war, because they would have no other choice once we actively attacked Germany)

Political Constraints

FDR could not afford to give more ammo to the isolationists, who already were outraged by the aforementioned actions. His political opponents were many and varied - from Nazis and Communists (although the latter switched sides on 1941-06-22) to traditionalists who love to mention Jefferson's "entangling alliances"Washington/Jefferson's "entangling alliances".

The even more important issue were the people. FDR understood that the war will be a hard fought all-out effort. He had to make sure that the people will keep morale high and not think "we provoked the war ourselves, it's our own fault, let's settle".

Note that during his reelection campaign Roosevelt pledged that he would "not send American boys into any foreign wars".

Industrial Constraints

Seriously, what could FDR do that he was not already doing? Building a battleship takes 2-3 years. Making 1000 strategic bombers takes similar time. Mobilization, training the troops, arming them takes time.

US was in no position to do anything it was not already doing.

See also the Details section in another answer.

why didn't America join the war after it sank?

Because, according to the Constitution (Article 1 Section 8), war is declared by Congress, and Congress was heavily isolationist.

Also, for all practical purposes, US was already at war:

When Hitler declared war on the US, he mentioned that "they are already fighting us anyway".

Constraints on FDR

As an extended reply to a comment

why didn't the President declare military action, based on the attack of one of their ships, (forcing Congress to go to war, because they would have no other choice once we actively attacked Germany)

Political Constraints

FDR could not afford to give more ammo to the isolationists, who already were outraged by the aforementioned actions. His political opponents were many and varied - from Nazis and Communists (although the latter switched sides on 1941-06-22) to traditionalists who love to mention Jefferson's "entangling alliances".

The even more important issue were the people. FDR understood that the war will be a hard fought all-out effort. He had to make sure that the people will keep morale high and not think "we provoked the war ourselves, it's our own fault, let's settle".

Industrial Constraints

Seriously, what could FDR do that he was not already doing? Building a battleship takes 2-3 years. Making 1000 strategic bombers takes similar time. Mobilization, training the troops, arming them takes time.

US was in no position to do anything it was not already doing.

See also the Details section in another answer.

why didn't America join the war after it sank?

Because, according to the Constitution (Article 1 Section 8), war is declared by Congress, and Congress was heavily isolationist.

Also, for all practical purposes, US was already at war:

When Hitler declared war on the US, he mentioned that "they are already fighting us anyway".

Constraints on FDR

As an extended reply to a comment

why didn't the President declare military action, based on the attack of one of their ships, (forcing Congress to go to war, because they would have no other choice once we actively attacked Germany)

Political Constraints

FDR could not afford to give more ammo to the isolationists, who already were outraged by the aforementioned actions. His political opponents were many and varied - from Nazis and Communists (although the latter switched sides on 1941-06-22) to traditionalists who love to mention Washington/Jefferson's "entangling alliances".

The even more important issue were the people. FDR understood that the war will be a hard fought all-out effort. He had to make sure that the people will keep morale high and not think "we provoked the war ourselves, it's our own fault, let's settle".

Note that during his reelection campaign Roosevelt pledged that he would "not send American boys into any foreign wars".

Industrial Constraints

Seriously, what could FDR do that he was not already doing? Building a battleship takes 2-3 years. Making 1000 strategic bombers takes similar time. Mobilization, training the troops, arming them takes time.

US was in no position to do anything it was not already doing.

See also the Details section in another answer.

4 typo
source | link

why didn't America join the war after it sank?

Because, according to the Constitution (Article 1 Section 8), war is declared by Congress, and Congress was heavily isolationist.

Also, for all practical purposes, US was already at war:

When Hitler declared war on the US, he mentioned that "they are already fighting us anyway".

Constraints on FDR

As an extenderextended reply to a comment

why didn't the President declare military action, based on the attack of one of their ships, (forcing Congress to go to war, because they would have no other choice once we actively attacked Germany)

Political Constraints

FDR could not afford to give more ammo to the isolationists, who already were outraged by the aforementioned actions. His political opponents were many and varied - from Nazis and Communists (although the latter switched sides on 1941-06-22) to traditionalists who love to mention Jefferson's "entangling alliances".

The even more important issue were the people. FDR understood that the war will be a hard fought all-out effort. He had to make sure that the people will keep morale high and not think "we provoked the war ourselves, it's our own fault, let's settle".

Industrial Constraints

Seriously, what could FDR do that he was not already doing? Building a battleship takes 2-3 years. Making 1000 strategic bombers takes similar time. Mobilization, training the troops, arming them takes time.

US was in no position to do anything it was not already doing.

See also the Details section in another answer.

why didn't America join the war after it sank?

Because, according to the Constitution (Article 1 Section 8), war is declared by Congress, and Congress was heavily isolationist.

Also, for all practical purposes, US was already at war:

When Hitler declared war on the US, he mentioned that "they are already fighting us anyway".

Constraints on FDR

As an extender reply to a comment

why didn't the President declare military action, based on the attack of one of their ships, (forcing Congress to go to war, because they would have no other choice once we actively attacked Germany)

Political Constraints

FDR could not afford to give more ammo to the isolationists, who already were outraged by the aforementioned actions. His political opponents were many and varied - from Nazis and Communists (although the latter switched sides on 1941-06-22) to traditionalists who love to mention Jefferson's "entangling alliances".

The even more important issue were the people. FDR understood that the war will be a hard fought all-out effort. He had to make sure that the people will keep morale high and not think "we provoked the war ourselves, it's our own fault, let's settle".

Industrial Constraints

Seriously, what could FDR do that he was not already doing? Building a battleship takes 2-3 years. Making 1000 strategic bombers takes similar time. Mobilization, training the troops, arming them takes time.

US was in no position to do anything it was not already doing.

See also the Details section in another answer.

why didn't America join the war after it sank?

Because, according to the Constitution (Article 1 Section 8), war is declared by Congress, and Congress was heavily isolationist.

Also, for all practical purposes, US was already at war:

When Hitler declared war on the US, he mentioned that "they are already fighting us anyway".

Constraints on FDR

As an extended reply to a comment

why didn't the President declare military action, based on the attack of one of their ships, (forcing Congress to go to war, because they would have no other choice once we actively attacked Germany)

Political Constraints

FDR could not afford to give more ammo to the isolationists, who already were outraged by the aforementioned actions. His political opponents were many and varied - from Nazis and Communists (although the latter switched sides on 1941-06-22) to traditionalists who love to mention Jefferson's "entangling alliances".

The even more important issue were the people. FDR understood that the war will be a hard fought all-out effort. He had to make sure that the people will keep morale high and not think "we provoked the war ourselves, it's our own fault, let's settle".

Industrial Constraints

Seriously, what could FDR do that he was not already doing? Building a battleship takes 2-3 years. Making 1000 strategic bombers takes similar time. Mobilization, training the troops, arming them takes time.

US was in no position to do anything it was not already doing.

See also the Details section in another answer.

3 Constraints on FDR
source | link

why didn't America join the war after it sank?

Because, according to the Constitution (Article 1 Section 8), war is declared by Congress, and Congress was heavily isolationist.

Also, for all practical purposes, US was already at war:

When Hitler declared war on the US, he mentioned that "they are already fighting us anyway".

Constraints on FDR

As an extender reply to a comment

why didn't the President declare military action, based on the attack of one of their ships, (forcing Congress to go to war, because they would have no other choice once we actively attacked Germany)

Political Constraints

FDR could not afford to give more ammo to the isolationists, who already were outraged by the aforementioned actions. His political opponents were many and varied - from Nazis and Communists (although the latter switched sides on 1941-06-22) to traditionalists who love to mention Jefferson's "entangling alliances".

The even more important issue were the people. FDR understood that the war will be a hard fought all-out effort. He had to make sure that the people will keep morale high and not think "we provoked the war ourselves, it's our own fault, let's settle".

Industrial Constraints

Seriously, what could FDR do that he was not already doing? Building a battleship takes 2-3 years. Making 1000 strategic bombers takes similar time. Mobilization, training the troops, arming them takes time.

US was in no position to do anything it was not already doing.

See also the Details section in another answer.

why didn't America join the war after it sank?

Because, according to the Constitution (Article 1 Section 8), war is declared by Congress, and Congress was heavily isolationist.

Also, for all practical purposes, US was already at war:

When Hitler declared war on the US, he mentioned that "they are already fighting us anyway".

Constraints on FDR

As an extender reply to a comment

why didn't the President declare military action, based on the attack of one of their ships, (forcing Congress to go to war, because they would have no other choice once we actively attacked Germany)

Political Constraints

FDR could not afford to give more ammo to the isolationists, who already were outraged by the aforementioned actions. His political opponents were many and varied - from Nazis and Communists (although the latter switched sides on 1941-06-22) to traditionalists who love to mention Jefferson's "entangling alliances".

The even more important issue were the people. FDR understood that the war will be a hard fought all-out effort. He had to make sure that the people will keep morale high and not think "we provoked the war ourselves, it's our own fault, let's settle".

Industrial Constraints

Seriously, what could FDR do that he was not already doing? Building a battleship takes 2-3 years. Making 1000 strategic bombers takes similar time. Mobilization, training the troops, arming them takes time.

US was in no position to do anything it was not already doing.

why didn't America join the war after it sank?

Because, according to the Constitution (Article 1 Section 8), war is declared by Congress, and Congress was heavily isolationist.

Also, for all practical purposes, US was already at war:

When Hitler declared war on the US, he mentioned that "they are already fighting us anyway".

Constraints on FDR

As an extender reply to a comment

why didn't the President declare military action, based on the attack of one of their ships, (forcing Congress to go to war, because they would have no other choice once we actively attacked Germany)

Political Constraints

FDR could not afford to give more ammo to the isolationists, who already were outraged by the aforementioned actions. His political opponents were many and varied - from Nazis and Communists (although the latter switched sides on 1941-06-22) to traditionalists who love to mention Jefferson's "entangling alliances".

The even more important issue were the people. FDR understood that the war will be a hard fought all-out effort. He had to make sure that the people will keep morale high and not think "we provoked the war ourselves, it's our own fault, let's settle".

Industrial Constraints

Seriously, what could FDR do that he was not already doing? Building a battleship takes 2-3 years. Making 1000 strategic bombers takes similar time. Mobilization, training the troops, arming them takes time.

US was in no position to do anything it was not already doing.

See also the Details section in another answer.

2 Constraints on FDR
source | link
1
source | link