Podcast #128: We chat with Kent C Dodds about why he loves React and discuss what life was like in the dark days before Git. Listen now.
2 Improved Formatting
source | link

Japan probably could have TRIED to take Hawaii with an all out follow up attack. Had they tried, they might have succeeded, or not.

But they never tried.

Why?

The main reason is, you have to remember the fundamentally FLAWEDflawed premise of Japan's war aim.

Japan didn't want an existential war with America.

Japan wanted a LIMITEDlimited war. Japan simply wanted to defang America's naval and air power in the Pacific, and negotiate a peace treaty with the US that would allow them to exploit all their Asian conquests.

Yes....Yes… Their war aim was to sucker punch America, kick americaAmerica while she is down, demand peace, and keep their ill gotten gains in Asia!

That was their big plan for World War Two. (that'sThat's also why they didn't ever fight Russia).

It was total wishful thinking. They didn't understand America. They didn't understand Americans.

But that was their basic premise.

So in their mind, taking Hawaii, would make America much less amendableamenable to a negotiated peace.

And they would have to return Hawaii in any negotiation anyway, so why even bother taking it? (and And yes it would have been costly, whether it was successful or not).

Japan probably could have TRIED to take Hawaii with an all out follow up attack. Had they tried, they might have succeeded, or not.

But they never tried.

Why?

The main reason is, you have to remember the fundamentally FLAWED premise of Japan's war aim.

Japan didn't want an existential war with America.

Japan wanted a LIMITED war. Japan simply wanted to defang America's naval and air power in the Pacific, and negotiate a peace treaty with the US that would allow them to exploit all their Asian conquests.

Yes.... Their war aim was to sucker punch America, kick america while she is down, demand peace, and keep their ill gotten gains in Asia!

That was their big plan for World War Two. (that's why they didn't ever fight Russia).

It was total wishful thinking. They didn't understand America. They didn't understand Americans.

But that was their basic premise.

So in their mind, taking Hawaii, would make America much less amendable to a negotiated peace.

And they would have to return Hawaii in any negotiation anyway, so why even bother taking it? (and yes it would have been costly, whether it was successful or not)

Japan probably could have TRIED to take Hawaii with an all out follow up attack. Had they tried, they might have succeeded, or not.

But they never tried.

Why?

The main reason is, you have to remember the fundamentally flawed premise of Japan's war aim.

Japan didn't want an existential war with America.

Japan wanted a limited war. Japan simply wanted to defang America's naval and air power in the Pacific, and negotiate a peace treaty with the US that would allow them to exploit all their Asian conquests.

Yes… Their war aim was to sucker punch America, kick America while she is down, demand peace, and keep their ill gotten gains in Asia!

That was their big plan for World War Two. That's also why they didn't ever fight Russia.

It was total wishful thinking. They didn't understand America. They didn't understand Americans.

But that was their basic premise.

So in their mind, taking Hawaii, would make America much less amenable to a negotiated peace.

And they would have to return Hawaii in any negotiation anyway, so why even bother taking it? And yes it would have been costly, whether it was successful or not.

1
source | link

Japan probably could have TRIED to take Hawaii with an all out follow up attack. Had they tried, they might have succeeded, or not.

But they never tried.

Why?

The main reason is, you have to remember the fundamentally FLAWED premise of Japan's war aim.

Japan didn't want an existential war with America.

Japan wanted a LIMITED war. Japan simply wanted to defang America's naval and air power in the Pacific, and negotiate a peace treaty with the US that would allow them to exploit all their Asian conquests.

Yes.... Their war aim was to sucker punch America, kick america while she is down, demand peace, and keep their ill gotten gains in Asia!

That was their big plan for World War Two. (that's why they didn't ever fight Russia).

It was total wishful thinking. They didn't understand America. They didn't understand Americans.

But that was their basic premise.

So in their mind, taking Hawaii, would make America much less amendable to a negotiated peace.

And they would have to return Hawaii in any negotiation anyway, so why even bother taking it? (and yes it would have been costly, whether it was successful or not)