7

Are Europe's fields filled to the brim with millions of casings? Or have they all been collected and recycled? What about the contemporary wars in Afghanistan and Iraq...are all the millions of spent shells just left in houses and streets?

It must add up to a fair amount of money if you were to recycle them all! Or is the value negligible?

What about the shells of artillery pieces? Are they just left?

Has there ever been a battle where a nation strapped for resources has made a point of collecting every shell casing?

Brass is a relatively valuable material, especially in such huge quantities.

  • 1
    Artillery shells usually explode on impact and the fragments rust in the earth. Casing containing valuable metal were mostly collected after the end of the war, together with the wrecks of the equipment. As a child, I collected a lot of cases as toys and souvenirs. – Alex Feb 16 at 0:13
9

Well, people from the generation that grew up right after the war told their kids (including me) of the treasure trove of unexploded ammunition they came across as the kids. The stories included numerous kids loosing finger or getting burned by powder, as well as occasional fatal explosions. Some schools even invited explosives experts to tell the kids how to handle them safely, based on the assumption that boys will be boys and won't leave ammunition alone, and the knowledge of how to handle it safely may save their lives.

The dangers of unexploded ammo didn't end with that generation though. A elementary school classmate of mine brought to school a mine he found somewhere so that he and his friends could take it apart and see what's inside. The three second graders lost their lives that day.

So-called "black archaeology" persists to this day in parts of Eastern Europe: people are digging up 70-year-old battlefields to find something valuable for sale, usually helmets and daggers, sometimes guns.

As for recycling casings, they were usually made of brass, a valuable metal, and there were plenty of location where one could sell them by weight.

  • 4
    Not just in East Europe - there are still the odd shell being found in France from WWI or WWII even now. – Oldcat Jul 25 '14 at 0:22
  • 4
    Odd shells! The French government recovers about 900 tons of unexploded ordinance a year! en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_harvest – DJohnM Jul 28 '14 at 1:26
  • Where I live in Oklahoma its still common to come across arrow heads. I can only imagine what it must be like in areas in Europe where automatic rifles were used in anger. – T.E.D. Jul 28 '14 at 14:26
  • 1
    Even in areas where they weren't (I live on the south coast of the UK, where lots of troops were based before D-Day) I still find plenty when I'm out and about in the countryside. When I was at school we had the same warnings about un-exploded munitions. A few years before I was at school someone, apparently, used a hacksaw on a .303 bullet and was badly hurt. – Kobunite Jul 28 '14 at 15:19
  • 1
    When I lived in Berlin during the 1980s on a UK base, I used to play in an old bunker - the bunker had several levels, most of which were inaccessible due to a lack of a ladder down a very deep shaft. In 1990, a rush project was started by the British military to excavate the lower levels because someone had made it down there and discovered a significant quantity of dumped WW2 ordnance in a very bad state. Enough to have caused a very nasty boom and a lot of deaths. The excavation showed the bunker was much much larger than anyone previously thought. – Moo Aug 20 at 1:14
3

As Michael says, people collect them as souvenirs. Military and other government agencies also collect them to prevent accidents.
Even to this day farmers in Europe plow up munitions and other trash from WW1 and WW2 regularly, mines, torpedoes and aircraft bombs are dredged up in fishing nets and when dredging rivers and harbours to deepen and widen shipping channels.
There's still areas (mostly forests but also coastal dunes) all over Europe that have warning signs around them warning against entry because they're WW2 minefields that have never been cleared.

Removing all the shell casings and bullet casings and melting them down for the metals may seem like a profitable idea, but if you consider that they're spread rather thin over a very large area, the work involved is extremely expensive. And what with the land being owned by many people, just getting permission from all those owners is more than tedious.
And of course after decades most of it will be buried, sometimes meters deep.

1

In Gaza they use spent shells as flower pots.

We're looking for long answers that provide some explanation and context. Don't just give a one-line answer; explain why your answer is right, ideally with citations. Answers that don't include explanations may be removed.

  • 1
    What is wrong with this answer? It is actually true. – fdb Jul 29 '14 at 17:29
  • 9
    1) Its a bit short. 2) It doesn't cover the regions mentioned in the question. 3) You don't make it clear if flower pots are the invariable end-use. 4) Citing some sources would be nice. 5) It seems more like a semi-humorous anecdote than a serious answer (though that may be OK here). – RedGrittyBrick Aug 1 '14 at 15:51
1

Hi I believe I can shed a little light on some of the uses for the shell casings after the war. About 2004 or thereabouts my sister, Frankie Heffernan and I lived in Raymond, WA and I was running a small shop that carried a variety of things including antiques and collectibles and I always had my sister looking for things for my shop.

In late 2004 she called me to tell me about some friends she had in Gig Harbor that were moving to Montana to be closer to their kids and they had a lot of things that they weren't taking with them so they were going to give me first choice if I came right away. Sis and I went up that day with a large moving truck because I had no idea what we were going to buy.

This was an elderly couple who were very gracious and had a home that he built by himself and it was not only breathtaking to see but it was also absolutely spotless and this was a 2 story home. In the living room were three large oriental cabinets with another one upstairs in their bedroom..I hope I still have a picture of one of them so you can see how beautiful they were. Each cabinet which measured 48 in length and 24 deep by 36 tall, had over 100 pieces of ornate brass including 8 pieces for the 4 way locking system that each one had.

I fell in love and bought the 3 that he was going to let go of for a very reasonable price and that when he told me about the cases. He was a pilot in WWII and stationed in Okinawa and there was also a Korean man who lived close to him and he built beautiful wood cabinets of all sizes. He became friends with the craftsman and asked if he could build him 4 large cases that would all have the kind of locking mechanisms that he put on others.

The cases were started in 1949 and then shipped to the U.S. in late 1950 and the pilot got to watch how the cases were made and that's when he found out that the brass pieces were from the shell casings that were found by a couple of his friends and sold to the Korean craftsman to melt down and prepare for use on the cases. The pilot said it was time consuming but the end product was unbelievable. I once had all of the information written down but I have moved several times and everything connected to my cases was lost. I will now make a better attempt at finding them.

  • 2
    Some paragraphs would improve this answer. – Semaphore Dec 26 '17 at 7:22
1

There are tons of unexploded shells ploughed up every year in the lowlands of Belgium and Northern France. Its known as the iron harvest.

While driving round the countryside of former battlefields you will see what looks like log stores at the gateway to fields or at crossroads but when you look closer you realise that the logs are unexploded ordinance. The army collects from these local collection points periodically and destroys them by controlled explosion in deserted areas. Some of them are armour piercing, some high explosive but by far the most sinister are the gas shells left over from both major conflicts.

1

Shells, tanks, etc., left behind in North Africa in WWII were so numerous that scrap metal was Libya's primary export for most of the 1950s (Ellen Lust, The Middle East, p.623). (Significant oil reserves weren't discovered there until 1959.)

0

The majority of tonnage of brass shell casings ended up in recycle. Anecdotally; it was such a substantial amount that a friends grandfather had a contract with the US Navy to collect brass shell casings in the Pacific theater ( no details).

  • To avoid downvotes, you could include a source for the first sentence (the downvote seems a little harsh given the anecdotal evidence). Perhaps google to see if there is any evidence of other contracts (to back up your anecdotal evidence). – Lars Bosteen Aug 18 at 23:06

protected by Pieter Geerkens Aug 18 at 19:58

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.