1

I thought buildings just kind of exists throughout history, and is not very important either But in my world history class, architecture is a subtheme that is discussed a lot in the textbook.

What does architectural styles tell us about a society? What kind of knowledge has historians gained from studying the buildings of a historical society?

closed as unclear what you're asking by Tea Drinker, Tyler Durden, Oldcat, Kobunite, American Luke Oct 13 '14 at 18:17

Please clarify your specific problem or add additional details to highlight exactly what you need. As it's currently written, it’s hard to tell exactly what you're asking. See the How to Ask page for help clarifying this question. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 3
    Not sure how "history" it is (or answerable for that matter), but an interesting question. For example, I've noticed that there seems to be a certain unique style to old African-American churches. Sort of a very understated brick Gothic. Perhaps I'm reading way too much into it, but it almost looks like they are trying to simultaneously look inconspicuous and like a relatively sturdy place to hide out from a lynch mob. – T.E.D. Oct 1 '14 at 2:31
  • and of course a lot of buildings tend to get lost in time. Only in the mid-late 20th century did people start to deliberately preserve and maintain certain buildings they considered "iconic" so as to keep them unchanged for the future. – jwenting Oct 1 '14 at 10:00
  • This is a question about architecture; "history" is only mentioned once, and there is no indication that you've done any research (for example, does the Educational Testing Service publish documentation that would answer your postscript?) This question seems more designed to elicit discussion than answers. – Mark C. Wallace Oct 1 '14 at 10:34
  • 1
    It sounds like one of those "do my homework for me" questions. – fdb Oct 2 '14 at 22:29
  • Ummm no. Idk what to say, but I'm just genuinely interested in history and the subject showed up in both my WHAP and English classes – louie mcconnell Oct 3 '14 at 1:45
9

There is a lot to learn about a society from its buildings, especially if you know what they are used for. For example, find the largest and most decorated buildings (not meaning just decoration, but things like enormous windows, big halls, dramatic stairways, no smaller buildings near them). Are they:

  • for religious activities?
  • for watching people compete or fight, possibly be hurt or die?
  • for shopping?
  • for watching people sing, dance, perform a play?
  • for generating electricity?
  • for processing sewage?
  • for making stuff (eg a car factory?)
  • for educating people?
  • for making the laws of the country?
  • for judging crimes?

Also look at the features of these important buildings compared to the same buildings elsewhere or at other times. For example, most castles in England were clearly defensive buildings, with thick walls, arrow slits, drawbridges etc. The chateaux of the Loire Valley are enormous buildings, but are basically just houses: if they have moats they tend to be a "water feature" more than a defense mechanism. They don't have arrow slits, or places for an army to gather before a battle. They have tons of doors and their great rooms are for dancing, not for the village to huddle together during a siege. All of this is obvious from the building itself, and tells you a lot about what life was like at that time in that place.

Also look at the large but non decorated buildings. Are they for living in? Working in? What happens a LOT (so you need big buildings) but isn't considered very important (so they're really nothing special)?

You can also look at the arrangement of buildings. Is everything centred around that big church or mall or stadium? Can you see it from everywhere else? Did the city grow from the waterfront back towards the hills? What is on the edge of town and what is in the heart of everywhere? Are there different parts of town for different things?

Then examine at the building level. Are activities mixed that other societies separate? For example, people once used to keep their animals in the same buildings as themselves. In some places, people work at home or live at work, and in others such activities never mix. In some houses there is a schoolroom to educate the children of the house: in others the children go to a completely different place to learn. How many bedrooms are there? How many bathrooms? In an office building, are there gender-segregated bathrooms? In an office building, are there large meeting rooms? Are some offices larger than others? Is there a room for recreation? Is there an attached daycare? Is there a place to put your bicycle? Does a residential apartment have a balcony? Is it for sitting on with a glass of wine, or for growing tomatoes?

Now all of this is harder when it's historical and you don't know what people did in the buildings or what the rooms were for. But you find stuff in the ruins, and maybe you have art showing things in use, and you can piece together a lot that way.

While it may not come up in general conversation, studying buildings from long ago is one of the ways your history textbook came to know the things it states to you so calmly as fact. Did most families own slaves? Were home vegetable gardens an important source of food? Did every village have a market square? Were the buildings near the docks mostly businesses with no-one living there? All that information is likely to have been pieced together by studying buildings. They just don't tell you in the book how they come to know these facts, instead concentrating on telling you the facts.

6

Most buildings are fundamentally functional, which means the architecture of a society also gives us an idea of how it's people lived. For example, earlier castles with no separate dining rooms for lords and peasants suggest that the two classes were closer than is usually the image of medieval life. Later layouts of separate quarters indicates that over time, the superiority of lord and his family over the rest of the manor became more entrenched.

Architecture is also a way for ancient cultures to express their religious and philosophical beliefs. The pyramids are a great example of lasting religious icons, but cases like the large numbers of Shiite shrines in Syria built during the Sunni period also tells us that the religious situation was more fluid and mixed than it seems when looking only at the political leadership.

  • you forget the most important buildings in most societies: farms. Of course they're not glorious, tend to not draw many tourists in centuries after (even if they survive being torn down and rebuilt in new styles), but they're the backbone of most societies, certainly those where there are no major cities. – jwenting Oct 1 '14 at 10:02
  • @jwenting are there old farms so common? Castles are built do endure wars, while I expect farms to be torn down and rebuilt quite often (hence having no historical value). – o0'. Oct 1 '14 at 12:20
  • 2
    @Lohoris he didn't specify the buildings must still exist today... You can refer a lot of information from archeological remains, photos, drawings, paintings, descriptions in surviving manuscripts. Heck, they've rebuilt entire stone age settlements based on dug up remains, and had volunteers live there for a while as experiments (and in some places you can still pay to live in those things for a few days). – jwenting Oct 1 '14 at 12:31
  • I agree farms, as in farmland, is important, but I don't think it's usually counted as a building... – user5001 Oct 1 '14 at 17:45

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.