19

In the Great Gatsby, in Chapter 9 Fitzgerald writes that Nick visited Meyer Wolfsheim and that he was in an office with a door marked "Swastika Holding Company."

The Great Gatsby was written between 1923 and 1925. I looked online and found that when Hitler was put in charge of his party's propaganda machine in 1920 he chose the swastika specifically because he felt that it was Aryan and anti-Semitic.

I'm interested to know the following:

1) Was the swastika a symbol that would have been used by a Jewish business owner in 1923 (or the approximate time of the novel)?

2) Would a reader in 1925 have associated this symbol with the National Socialist Party or was the party still relatively unknown such that it's main symbol would not have been known to people until later?

  • 39
    Where did you get the idea that Hitler "chose the swastika specifically because it was anti-semitic"? As a symbols, swatiska-shaped geometric patterns were very popular designs with long traditions in many cultures. – Semaphore Jan 30 '16 at 10:51
  • 1
    When I visited Tibet a few years ago, they used the swastika in decoration a lot. Also, a few years ago it made the news that a textile corporation bought some models of handbags in India and imported then into Israel -nobody noticed the bags decoration...-. IIRC, they associate the symbol with good luck, and to them it means nothing else. – SJuan76 Jan 30 '16 at 11:23
  • 16
    Maybe you should read the Wikipedia item on the Swastika (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swastika). It's origins go back to 10,000 BCE & it was once the symbol of the 45th Infantry Division of the US Army as well as the symbol for the Finnish air force from 1918 to 1945. The Finnish air force adopted it before Hitler usurped it for his nefarious purposes – Fred Jan 30 '16 at 11:25
  • 2
    The Great Gatsby takes place in the summer of 1922, the year before Hitler tried his failed putsch, for which he spent a year in prison. The book was published in 1925. Hitler got out of prison in December 1924. I doubt anyone in the US was paying attention to AH at the beginning of the Roaring '20s. – deadrat Jan 31 '16 at 4:22
  • 3
    Could the (fictional) Swastika Holding Company be meant to be associated with the (real) Swastika Mine, located in Swastika, Ontario ?en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swastika,_Ontario – DJohnM Jan 31 '16 at 17:32
32

Hitler did not choose the symbol because it was "anti-Semitic". Nowhere in the web article you cite in the comments does it say any such thing. It says, quote, the swastika "...traditionally had been a sign of good fortune and well being...". What the article says is more or less correct. At the time the swastika was an extremely common decoration and symbol both in India and China. Originally it was probably a symbol for the sun, but by the 20th century that was long forgotten and most Chinese just considered it a "good luck" symbol. In 1920, you could find the symbol on every street in Shanghai.

In the United States, the swastika was perceived as an exotic, ancient symbol and associated with mysticism and kitschy fortune telling. At the time there were many cockeyed theories about "secret, forgotten ancient civilizations". Here is a typical example of a magazine article writing about such theories as though they were fact:

[After the flood] we find a brown-skinned people establishing parallel civilizations in fertile lands close to the shores of the inland sea--the Mediterranean. We find the Sumerians in Mesopotamia, in the valley of the Tigris and Euphrates, and the Egyptians in the valley of the Nile. And, what is strangest of all, we find traces of the same sort of people and the same sort of culture, distributed in far separated lands--in India, China, Central America, Mexico, and even in England. Distinguishing this culture are certain common characteristics, such as the building of crude stone (megalithic) monuments, the making of mummies, and the use of the symbol known as the "swastika" for good luck.

Popular Science August 1925

So here we see in Popular Science an example of one of these nutty amateur anthropological theories parroted as though it were a well-accepted fact.

In the Great Gatsby, the character Wolfsheim is given the word for his company by the author to evoke a sense of exotic, mystical superstition. For example, Wolfsheim has cuff links made out of human molars, another example of his weird, superstitious nature.

  • 7
    The article says "...Hitler concluded that the swastika had been eternally anti Semitic." It's not a stretch then to say that he chose it because he felt it was anti Semitic. In any case, good answer. Thank you. – michael_timofeev Jan 30 '16 at 15:59
  • 1
    Care to add the link (page 37 btw): books.google.ca/… – Pieter Geerkens Jan 30 '16 at 20:14
  • 7
    @michael_timofeev I wouldn't give much credence to what Hitler concluded. The swastika is a Sanskrit name, and the symbol was in use in Germany before World War I to support various crackpot racial theories of the German volkish descent from ancient Aryan cultures. – deadrat Jan 31 '16 at 4:16
  • @michael_timofeev I hope you're not worried that I think your question is without value or out of order. – deadrat Jan 31 '16 at 4:58
  • @michael_timofeev Perhaps I misunderstood your comment, which seemed to be an unbidden defense of the purpose of your asking the questions. I wanted to assure that you've no need to justify your queries to me. It is of utter indifference to me how you choose to receive that, but it is nevertheless true. – deadrat Jan 31 '16 at 5:25
22

The swastika was used as a logo for the Danish beer company Carlsberg from 1880 to 1940, so it was not considered political by the large part of the population, at least not until the 1930'ies

Carlsberg symbols swastkia

  • Didn't know that one :) – Rohit Jan 31 '16 at 12:42
  • The Ny Carlsberg Glyptotek's premises (a well renown art museum in Copenhagen founded by a son of Carlsberg) also shows the swastika quite prominently. – Ghanima Jan 31 '16 at 22:19
  • So did the US Army's 45th Infantry Division, and illustrations and covers of many Rudyard Kipling books. The use for marking the location of Buddhist temples on Japanese maps was only discontinued in recent weeks. – Jon Hanna Feb 1 '16 at 14:35
14

After the Beer Hall Putsch of Nov. 8, 1923, the Nazi Party was banned in Germany (though it continued to operate clandestinely) until being refounded by Hitler in 1925. Thus although the swastika had been adopted as an emblem of the Nazi Party in 1921, during the time at which The Great Gatsby was written there would not have been a strong association with the Nazi Party.

One should note that following the discovery of swastika representations during Heinrich Schliemann's excavation of Troy:

[Schliemann] connected it with similar shapes found on pottery in Germany and speculated that it was a “significant religious symbol of our remote ancestors.”

In the beginning of the twentieth century the swastika was widely used in Europe. It had numerous meanings, the most common being a symbol of good luck and auspiciousness. However, the work of Schliemann soon was taken up by völkisch movements, for whom the swastika was a symbol of “Aryan identity” and German nationalist pride.

  • Ok, so at the time, it would have been a good luck symbol just like any other and could have been found on someone's door, regardless of religious background? – michael_timofeev Jan 30 '16 at 11:05
  • 1
    @michael_timofeev: Yes; and might even be chosen as a way of emphasizing pride in one's German heritage. Routine anti-Semitism was still standard across much Western Europe (as well as North America), which most Jews would have merely accepted at that time. – Pieter Geerkens Jan 30 '16 at 11:08
7

In Russia swastika was considered an "Asian symbol" at the time. During Russian civil war, swastika was adopted as a symbol of Kalmyk units of the South-East front of the Red Army.

Here is the decree, establishing it as an armbadge: enter image description here

Here is the actual armbadge:

enter image description here

Swastika is called "«ЛЮНГТН» sign" in the description, it is unclear what the acronym stands for. The South-East front used it as an award badge as well:

enter image description here


The Whites also used the symbol extensively. The Asian Cavalry Division, a Cossack formation headed by baron von Ungern-Sternberg who captured the Mongol capital Urga, had Mongol and Tibetan units. Austrian by birth, Ungern himself married a Mongol princess and adopted Mongolian clothing style.

enter image description here

His superior, ataman Semeonov, also reported (by General Leutnant K.V. Sakharov) to wear shoulder badges with "the sign of Mongolian Suuvastika". Osednovsky reports that the Mongolian formations of the division used shoulder badges with swastika.

enter image description here

enter image description here

It is also reported that Ungern was awarded with a ring with swastika, allegedly beloged to Chengis Khan.

Ungern's adjutant and division's commandant N.N. Kneazev reports "holy yellow flag with a sign of Chengiz Khan (swastika), which became for the whites and the Mongolian people the symbol of struggle against the Communists".

The French historian Gerson also reports the division to use flags with swastika.

Himself, baron Ungern adopted Buddhism, while still retaining Christianity (he was Luteran). He was a staunch Monarchist and dreamed about restoration of Chenghis Khan empire that would govern both Europe and Asia and prevent revolutions. He also tried to create "Order of military Buddhists", also known as "Order of Buddhist Crusaders".

Since baron Ungern conducted proto-Nazi policy (killinng all Jews and Communists on site), I suspect that his army was in fact the very reason why Hitler has adopted Swastika: there were a lot of White emigrants in Germany at the time, and they could very well influence Hitler who possibly considered Ungern's army as an example.

It is possible, Hitler adopted other his ideas from Ungern's ideology as well: during a discussion with another White officer General Molchanov about what to do with the Jews, Ungern-Sternberg stated that it was necessary to "exterminate the Jews, so that neither men nor women, nor even the seed of this people remain"

Wikipedia tells:

Alongside Ungern-Sterberg's aristocratic pride was an ardent anti-Slavic racism that led him to view all Slavic peoples as naturally inferior and barbarous to the "superior" Volkdeutsche (ethnic Germans) like himself.[ 10 ] Ungern-Sternberg believed that it was the Volkdeutsche nobility of the Russian empire who were the Herrnvolk ("master race") that kept the empire working, and that if the Slavic Russians were left on their own that they would inevitably fall for the tricks of the Jews, whom the anti-Semitic Ungern-Sterberg saw as his archenemies from his childhood on.[ 10 ]

(...)

Dr. Klingenberg, a fellow Baltic German who was close to Ungern because he was one of the few officers who spoke German as his first language was a Social Darwinist who believed in the "survival of the fittest" suggested to Ungern that he be allowed to poison those wounded and sick soldiers who were "unfit", an idea that Ungern gave his approval to.[77] Dozens upon dozens of Ungern's sick and wounded soldiers were poisoned by Dr. Klingenberg, who was so enthusiastic about killing his patients that many ill soldiers preferred not to visit the hospital, least they fall victim to Klingenberg.[77]

(...)

After the battle, Ungern staged a pogrom against the Russian Jewish refugees living in Urga as he led his Cossacks against the Jews, ordering that all Jews be killed as he stated, "in my opinion, the Jews are not protected by any law".[101] The Mongols, who had no tradition of anti-Semitism, did not understand why Ungern wanted to slaughter the Jews, and as Ungern led a Jewish baker named Moshkovich, renowned for his kindness, away to be hacked to pieces, many ordinary people were heard to ask "What harm has he done, this good old man?", only to brushed aside.[101] In Russia, gang rape had always been an integral part of the pogroms, though usually only men were killed in pogroms.[102] In the Urga pogrom, gang rape was very common, but this time women and children were killed as Ungern gave orders to kill every Jew without regard to age or sex.[103] Prince Togtokh, a Mongol prince famed as an anti-Chinese guerilla fighter and until then one of Ungern's strongest allies, had attempted to hide some Jews in his house that he just reclaimed from the Chinese.[102] Ungern stormed into Togtokh's house, had the Jews taken out to be beaten to death on the streets and when Prince Togtokh protested at this violation of the sacred Mongol law of hospitality, nearly had him hanged.[102] When a Danish missionary named Olsen protested, Ungern had him tied to a horse and killed by dragging him through the streets.[102] So many bodies were left on the streets of Urga that packs of wild dogs started to devour the dead.[104]


Now one more example of usage of Swastika at the time. There was Swastika symbol on the banknotes of the Russian Provisional Government of 1917:

enter image description here

The swastika is described simply as "geometric ornament" in the official description of the banknotes, but the underlying reason is deeper.

The banknotes were produced from the designs originally intended for Mongolian National Bank. The bank's headquarters were to be located in Petrograd and its banknotes were planned to be printed by the Petrograd Mint.

There are specimens of this currency that remained: enter image description here

enter image description here

enter image description here


In conclusion, in all the mentioned examples Swastika was intended as an Asian (specifically, Mongolic) symbol.

  • 3
    +1. I don't know how true is your "Ungern -> Hitler" theory, but sure is fascinating. – Brasidas Jan 10 '17 at 2:42
  • 2
    @Brasidas in the 1920s, D.H. Lawrence wrote: ”the great leaning of the German spirit is once more eastwards, towards Russia, towards Tartary [...] The positivity of our civilization has broken. The influences that come, come invisibly out of Tartary. So that all Germany reads Beasts, Men, and Gods [a "non-fiction" bestseller by the Polish writer Ferdinand Ossendowski about his adventures with Ungern] with a kind of fascination. Returning again to the fascination of the destructive East, that produced Atilla.”. This means, the story of Ungern was read by "all Germany" in 1920s. – Anixx Jan 10 '17 at 2:53
  • 2
    @Brasidas harpers.org/blog/2010/03/… Given it was a "bestseller" in Germany, Hitler could borrow from this book clinical anti-Bolshevism, genocidal anti-Semitism, alliance with the Asians, religious tolerance, swastika, medical killings, death camps, treatment of Slavs as slaves etc. Only his distaste for Monarchy and nobility, pro-worker attitude contradicts Ungern's ideology. – Anixx Jan 10 '17 at 2:57
  • 1
    Ah, I was close to mention Ossendowski's book (which sadly I still have not read). What I didn't know is how famous it was back then. Thanks for the comments! Wish I could upvote twice :) – Brasidas Jan 10 '17 at 3:00
  • 2
    @Brasidas from the book: "Occasionally one saw the soldiers of Baron Ungern rushing about in long blue coats; Mongols and Tibetans in red coats with yellow epaulets bearing the swastika of Jenghiz Khan and the initials of the Living Buddha" So, it is possible, Hitler adopted it as a symbol of Chengiz Khan, not as an "Aryan symbol", actually. I wonder, whether there is historical evidence that Chenghiz Khan in fact used swastika as his main symbol? – Anixx Jan 10 '17 at 5:20
2

Question:
Is the swastika in The Great Gatsby anti-semitic?

Given that it's used on the doors of an ethnically jewish character I don't believe the swastikas are meant to be anti-semitic so much as they are meant to denote other properties of the Nazi party, brutality, criminality, and ruthlessness. After Mein Kaumf is published in the 1930's and especially after WWII the Nazi's are primarily associated with Anti semitism. In 1925 it's reasonable that Fitzgerald uses them as a mere symbol of criminality. A shady violent criminal organization seemingly and un-expectantly above the law in Germany. But yes Fitzgerald was referencing the Nazi party by placing those symbols on Wolfsheim's door.

Short Answer:

The answer to this question isn't just about History and the known use of the swastika by other cultures. This question rather relies heavily on the book the Great Gatsby itself and who Meyer Wolfsheim was in that literary work. Wolfsheim in the book is an organized Crime figure who wear's human teeth for cuff links, suggesting he may have cannibalistic tendencies. His name invokes the image of a predator of German origins. After WWI any association with Germany would have made him suspicious to an American audience; but he's associated with Rosy Rosenthal, the man who fixed Baseball's World Series. Wolfsheim said to have ties to organized crime in Europe. Prior to the events retold in the book Wolfsheim helped Gatsby make his fortune by importing illegal liquor into the United States from Europe in violation of the Volstead act. Given all this, the swastikas on his door are a non subtle reference to the Nazi party which an audience in 1925 would have recognized.

Detailed Answer

The swastikas on the door of Meyer Wolfsheim's office were a reference to the Nazi party. Maybe not the Nazi's we know today, post WW2, but a referee to a German underground crime organization in Fitzgerald's time. The Nazi party began using the swastika in 1920. November 8-9 1923 during the beer hall putsch and subsequent trial, February-April 1924 hitler became internationally famous as did the Nazi Party. Hitler would serve a little over 8 month and was fined 500 marks for the attempted overthrow of the German republic in which 4 police officers were killed. That putsch almost worked except for the timely intervention of a few key players. Hitler's lite sentence for such a serious crime told the world the Nazi party was a powerful crime organization with deep roots inside of Germany. Hitler's unapologetic testimony in court was defiant in which he claimed full responsibility for the putsch. His constant theme throughout his internationally covered, spectacle of a trial was that he was the leader of the putsch, de Furor. Hitler lectured the court and through the court Germany on why his attempted coupe was justified. Hitler's fame was greatly elevated during that trial as were the Nazi's.

The Great Gatsby written about the summer of 1922, but written in 1925. Fitzgerald and the contemporary audience would have been aware of Adolf Hitler, the Nazi Party and their association with the symbol especially on the door of a organized crime figure, with a ruthless reputation and with a German sounding name. Fitzgerald is using the symbology to send a message to the reader. To tell us something about Meyer Wolfsheim, or at least surround Wolfsheim with the symbolism his character is associated with.

1) Was the swastika a symbol that would have been used by a Jewish business owner in 1923 (or the approximate time of the novel)?

No, the point of Fitzgerald using the swastika was to tell us that something was shaddy about Meyer Wolfsheim. In the novel Wolfsheim helped Gatsby make his fortune by bootlegging liquor using his contacts in Europe with shady organizations which in 1925 included the Nazi's. Wolfsheim's continued association with Gatsby is supposed to suggest to the reader that Gatsby is still involved in illegal business. Fitzgerald is taking advantage of the contemporary notoriety of the Nazi's which in the mid 1920's was basically synonymous with German organized crime.

2) Would a reader in 1925 have associated this symbol with the National Socialist Party or was the party still relatively unknown such that it's main symbol would not have been known to people until later?

Yes. That's the point. The symbolism is supposed to be recognized and further color the reader's perception of one of Gatsby's close friends. Someone who Fitzgerald is telling the reader is a shady character.

  • +1 for the literary focus and also for pointing out that in 1925, the Nazi brand had organized crime connotations, not the wartime and post-war association's that we usually think of (blitzkrieg, Panzer tanks, firing squads, death camps). – Mike Supports Monica Dec 31 '18 at 1:08
2

It meant Peace and Harmony. In Buddhism and Asian cultures where it originated, it still does. They’re commonly used in Asian countries without any political connotations.

Internationally, the Nazi party would not have been well-known at this point. They were a minor party with extremist views and the German government at the time was not very effective and the economy was struggling. No reasonable pundit at this point would have thought they would get into power, nor did Germany play a significant role in international politics at the time.

Outside of Germany, Nazi imagery or any connection to them is unlikely to have been known. Equating anyone using the swastika as anti-semitic at this time is the same as accusing Japan today of anti-semitism. It simply isn’t the case. They use the symbol for it’s original meaning in Asian culture and are completely ignorant that it had been co-opted by an extremist political group in Germany. Even though they are now infamous among the Western world now, they were not significant then.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.