2

How would I know that Constitutional amendments were ratified on certain dates? What evidence would I have?

For example, a search result from the Library of Congress website states that the 15th Amendment was ratified on Feb 3, 1870.

But why should I believe it? After all, the search result also says that Secretary of State Hamilton Fish issued a proclamation of the 15th Amendment on March 30, 1870 (not Feb 3, 1870), and that the public began to recognize the amendment afterwards.

The Article V of the Constitution says that a proposed amendment is ratified when 3/4 of the states approve it. So then, shouldn't there be a record of someone officially validating the 3/4 poll of the states?

  • Why do you think ratification and promulgation must occur on the same day? – Semaphore Feb 2 '16 at 14:47
  • @Semaphore Okay I agree that they can be on different dates. But I still do not know where to find documents for ratification (I know that promulgation appears in the United States Statutes at Large). – PseudoJD Feb 3 '16 at 17:32
  • You'd have to look at state legislature archives to see when/where each amendment was ratified, and figure out which was the deciding vote. But if you don't trust sources like the Library of Congress then... =/ – Semaphore Feb 3 '16 at 19:01
  • 1
    @TylerDurden I, for one, welcome our chronologically challenged Reptilian overlords. – IllusiveBrian Feb 3 '16 at 21:03
1

The particular discrepancy in the 15th amendment is between when the 28th state (of 37) ratified it pushing it over the 3/4 necessary, and when that ratification was certified by the US Secretary of State. Iowa became the 28th on Feb 3rd, and the Secretary certified it on March 30th.

The secretary's certification was unnecessary. An amendment goes into effect the moment the final state ratification pushes it over the edge. This was upheld in DILLON v GLOSS.

The provisions of the act which the petitioner was charged with violating and under which he was arrested (title 2, §§ 3, 26) were by the terms of the act (title 3, § 21) to be in force from and after the date when the Eighteenth Amendment should go into effect, and the latter by its own terms was to go into effect one year after being ratified. Its ratification, of which we take judicial notice, was consummated January 16, 1919. That the Secretary of State did not proclaim its ratification until January 29, 1919, is not material, for the date of its consummation, and not that on which it is proclaimed, controls.

As for the evidence, presumably someone, somewhere has the original ratification documents in storage. Probably the US National Archives or the Iowa State Archives. Here's an example, Tennessee ratifying the 19th amendment, that was put on exhibit.

Tennessee ratifies the 19th amendment

Source: National Archives and Records Administration, Records of the U.S. House of Representatives

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.