18

According to Britannica's online article on Hagia Sophia:

The original church on the site of the Hagia Sophia is said to have been built by Constantine I in 325 on the foundations of a pagan temple.

The article does not list a source for this information and I can't seem to find any further information about it. Is there any evidence Hagia Sophia was built on the foundations of a pagan temple?

  • 1
    I would expect that any existing foundations would have been excavated and replaced with something more suitable for the size of the Hagia Sophia. So... are you asking for "on foundations" or "in same location"? If "on foundations", are you asking about the Hagia Sophia or Constantine's first church at that location? Are you asking for corporeal evidence (as in, "stones"), or would documents satisfy? -- All that being said, I seriously doubt that any "pagan" evidence from the 4th century survived, even if it were the case. – DevSolar Jul 6 '17 at 10:44
  • 2
    @DevSolar: That is proven false, as noted here concerning remains found of earlier temples: "Remains found during the excavations led by A. M Scheinder of the Istanbul German Archeology Institute, 2 meters below ground level, include steps belonging to the Propylon (monumental door), column bases and pieces with lamb embossings that represent the 12 apostles. In addition, other architectural pieces that belong to the monumental entrance can be seen in the west garden.." – Pieter Geerkens Jul 8 '17 at 6:44
  • Christianity often took over the sites (and customs) of the old religions, because the place itself was already sacred in the eyes of the locals. In the crypts of many cathedrals these days you can see the remains of old temples, lovingly excavated and restored. If the new one was much bigger they left the foundations of the old one in place and built around them. – RedSonja Jul 10 '17 at 10:37
  • As far as I know, there does not appear to be any evidence indicating that The Hagia Sophia was built over a pagan temple, though it can't be entirely ruled out either. Ancient "Byzantium"-(as it was originally called), was a city with its own buildings and mini Forum; a few of the ancient ruins still exist within present-day Istanbul, so it is not entirely impossible for there to have been pagan temples in the city during antiquity. However, at this point in time, there is no evidence, that I am aware of, which leads to the existence or survival of any pagan temples within present-day...... – user26763 Nov 19 '17 at 2:24
  • Istanbul-(and its immediate surroundings and environs). – user26763 Nov 19 '17 at 2:25
22
+50

Going beyond E.B. or Wikipedia:

The official website of the Hagia Sophia Museum states

The first church [at the H.S. site] was constructed by Emperor Konstantios [i.e. Constantine's son] (337-361) in 360. The first church was covered with a wooden roof and expanded vertically (basilica) yet was burned down after the public riot that took place in 404 as a result of the disagreements between Emperor Arkadios’ (395-408) wife empress Eudoksia and Istanbul’s patriarch Ioannes Chrysostomos, who was exiled. [...] No remains have been recovered from the first church; however, the bricks found in the museum storage branded ‘Megale Ekklesia’ are predicted to belong to the first construction.

The website Hagia Sophia says

Known as the “Great Church” or “Magna Ecclesia” in Latin, the first church was built at the same location where there had been a pagan temple before [emphasis mine]. It was Constantius II who inaugurated Hagia Sophia on 15 February 360. From the chronicles of Socrates of Constantinople, we know that the church was built by the orders of Constantine the Great.

Prokopius' book Buildings of Justinian, a translation of which was kindly linked to by @user2448131 gives a detailed description of the Hagia Sophia, its construction, and its beginnings post Nika revolt, but does not make any mention of pagan "foundations".

As for other historical source, there seems to be a distinct dearth when searching on that topic: there are many sites or excerpts with circular quoting referring to the pagan temple. This one stating

Some say that the site was first a pagan temple in honor of Apollo and Venus.

Which is one of the few that actually identifies the deities. As a number of other sources state Greek temple, we'll have to presume that would have been Aphrodite?

Here is a most intriguing abstract about the construction of the Hagia Sophia. It was actually designed by a pagan! Sadly the site requires registration and acedemic credentials.

A figure overlooked in scholarship on Hagia Sophia is Phokas, the praetorian prefect of 532 under whom construction of the church began. He was a pagan who eventually took his own life in one of Justinian’s purges. His initial supervision of the construction of Hagia Sophia is attested by Ioannes Lydos, himself a pagan intellectual, who praised Phokas in superlative terms, despite Phokas’ infamous death. Consideration of all the evidence for an architect of Hagia Sophia, Anthemios of Tralleis, beyond the literary sources usually cited, strongly suggests that he belonged to the pagan wing of the school of Ammonios of Alexandria, as did the architect Isidoros of Miletos. Material presented here explains how the last pagans of New Rome contributed to the making of Hagia Sophia and suggests how they may have interpreted the monument on their own terms.

On the spur of the moment, I contacted, going first via Prof. Mary Beard, her husband Prof. Robin Cormack, specialist in Byzantinistic or, as Wikipedia states, he is a British classicist and art historian, specialising in Byzantine art. He was Professor in the History of Art, Courtauld Institute of Art, University of London, 1991–2004. Despite traveling in Turkey as I write this, he was kind enough to respond he writes:

Just a short answer as we are in Turkey just now. Archaeologically there is no clear indication, as the Constantinian church underneath the present church has not been excavated. In the course of time all sorts of mythic stories about the city and its origins developed. There is a really good book about this - Gilbert Dagron, Constantinople imaginaire . He collects all the stories and assesses them

The title of the book sounds French, so I'd either have to brush up a lot on my rudimentary knowledge or some other kind soul, fluent in French, can provide information from that book.

  • Comments are not for extended discussion; this conversation has been moved to chat. – T.E.D. Jul 7 '17 at 13:08
  • @user2448131 Thank you! I've edited that paragraph and credited you. Unless I'm blind, Procopius detailed description and background of the HS makes no mention of a pagan temple on the original site. – Marakai Jul 8 '17 at 13:39
  • I added some information from an expert on the subject – Marakai Jul 9 '17 at 7:08
  • @marakai thank you for your amazing effort. Much appreciated! – Notaras Jul 9 '17 at 13:50

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.