1

I am thinking in a list of all peace negotiations, forced or not, successful or not. So far I can think of several:

  • Germany annexed Poland.
  • Peace with Netherlands after invading it.
  • Peace with Denmark after invading it.
  • Germany negotiated peace with France in 1940.
  • Rudolf Hess tried to negotiate a peace with UK in 1941... on his own?
  • I think Himmler negotiated a possible peace with UK and USA.
  • German surrender in 1945.

Am I missing more attempts? Maybe this one during Dunkirk battle? Any other?

  • 10
    Note that some of these were unconditional surrenders, so "peace negotiations" doesn't quite describe what happened. – Denis de Bernardy Aug 31 '17 at 17:57
  • How do you count "times"? – Alex Aug 31 '17 at 19:21
  • 1
    Not sure why you're attracting so many downvotes. You might remove the word "Exactly" from the title; it may be provocatie for some. This is a list question, which are difficult for SE sites (there is no way to obtain a single authoritative answer). Might be useful to provide links in your bullets. None of this is mandatory, just exploring why the question is below zero. Good luck – Mark C. Wallace Aug 31 '17 at 22:07
  • 1
    The question I would ask here would concern what possible value there could be in having an answer to such a question as this, even assuming everyone were agreed on what to include and what was meant by "peace negotiations". – WS2 Aug 31 '17 at 22:16
9

Well, you have omitted several countries that Germany conquered, including Belgium, Greece, Luxembourg, Norway and Yugoslavia. For your definition of peace negotiations, it's worth checking those.

Hess' intention to negotiate never stood a chance. It's never been quite clear what his offer was, but he seems to have been operating under a fundamental misunderstanding of the British form of government. He imagined that the Duke of Hamilton, whom he'd apparently met briefly at the Berlin Olympics, could get him an audience with the King even if the government was opposed to it. Once he had that audience, he expected that the King would be happy to fire the whole government and install a new one that would side with Germany. This might make sense if you assumed that the British government worked exactly like that of Imperial Germany, including Kaiser Wilhelm II's personality flaws, and that most of the British people wanted to join Germany's side but the government was in thrall to Germany's Jewish-Bolshevik enemies. That conspiracy theory was at the root of Nazism, and tended to wreck committed Nazis' attempts to work with other political systems. Also, his credibility evaporated when his mission was disowned by Hitler.

Himmler wanted to negotiate with the Americans and British, and certainly asked people in Sweden to arrange for negotiations. That seems to have been as far as it got, because news of it leaked out, leading to him being fired as a traitor by Hitler. Himmler's negotiating position is known, which was that he and the SS were vital to maintaining order in Germany, and that obviously the Western Allies would be happy to join with Germany in making war on the Soviet Union. Given the Allies' actual attitude to the work of the SS, this was never going anywhere. By the end stages of WWII, it was clear that the West and the USSR were going to have difficult relations afterwards, but Nazi Germany was worse, and they were going to deal with that first.

On the "peace negotiations during Dunkirk", the author in question, Stephen Davis seems to work mostly in the field of sensationalised history. Express.co.uk, where the story appeared, is a highly unreliable source. It's above the level of an American supermarket tabloid, but not by much. It concentrates on trying to make the memories of its elderly readership seem important, and in sensationalising anything that might help with the health problems of the elderly. That is its agenda. You can see how this story fits right into the first part.

2

I don't believe that the German government ever attempted to negotiate an end to the war. Individuals did, which was actually more defection than negotiation. It was more the other way around. Germany betrayed agreements with other countries.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.