1

I've heard about hyperinflation in Germany right after WW1, and also in West Germany right after WW2. However, I've never heard of hyperinflation in Nazi Germany during WW2.

It seems a very typical government response, when they really need to buy things in an emergency, is to just print more money. So I'm wondering if this did or did not happen in Germany in 1939 - 1945, and why or why not.

  • 2
    Expecting a row of terrible responses to this. Whoever wants to answer this: "Money" is not conveniently or congruently identical to printed paper or bars of metal. – LаngLаngС Feb 25 '18 at 20:46
  • 1
    No. And it's not just a "government response". – Reinstate Monica - M. Schröder Feb 26 '18 at 6:35
  • @MartinSchröder Can you elaborate? Only the govt. can legally print money, so how could it not be a govt. response? – DrZ214 Feb 26 '18 at 8:43
  • 1
    @DrZ214: What you mean is called base money; banks create broad money. Today most money is broad money. – Reinstate Monica - M. Schröder Feb 26 '18 at 10:53
6

tl;dr There was no hyperinflation in Germany during or after World War 2. There was a degree of inflation which was dealt with by rationing basic consumer goods (starting even before the war), but no hyperinflation as seen in the case of 1923 Germany or Zimbabwe. This is mainly because Germany in and after World War 2 had rationing and price controls and a much more controlled economy than in 1923.

The connection of inflation, hyperinflation and government spending

To finance expenditure, governments theoretically have multiple choices (and traditionally employ a mixture of them). Among others: First, they can raise taxes and pay with the tax income. Second, they can issue bonds, which are basically loans to the government, sold to primarily banks. Governments promise to repay them and pay interest on them. Third, they can have the central bank issue more money to pay for government expenditure (unless they have an independent central bank as most Western countries do today). This what is referred to as ''print money'', but does, in modern economies, not typically involve literally priniting anything.

Inflation can arise - among other possible causes - from issuing quantities of money beyond the capacity of the economy. Specifically, if the quantity of money used to pay for goods exceeds the amount of goods, either the price of those goods will increase (as is the case with inflation) or some of the demand will not be served (as is the case with price controls and rationing). However, it is a bit more complicated since the money supply is not identical to the quantity of money used to pay for goods. The economy may have a lot of money without actually trying to use it for things that are not there. Among other things, this depends crucially on whether people believe in the stability of the currency. If they suddenly do not, they will - frantically - try to get their savings into alternative forms of investments. In such cases, demand for money (people wanting to sell something else for money) erodes to zero while supply of money (people wanting to buy something else for money in order to get rid of it) skyrockets. With this, the value of money collapses as well. Once an economy reaches this point, it is very difficult to recover from this situation; in most cases only a currency reform (in order to restore confidence) helps.

Hyperinflation in Germany after World War 1

Germany ran a huge deficit during World War 1, which was mainly paid for by government bonds that would be due after the war. As long as victory seemed conceivable, and with it the possibility that the France or Russia or whoever might pay war reparations to Germany, these bonds seemed like a sensible (and patriotic) investment. Germany also ran a deficit after the war, caused by the collapse of the war economy, unemployment, social turmoil, and reparations Germany had to pay to other countries. Only this time, the case for buying government bonds was a lot less convincing; so they needed to find an alternative way to pay for this. They increased the money supply, they kept doing this beyond the capacity of the economy, confidence in the currency collapsed, and you get the inflation scenario described above. Instead of instituting a currency reform, they kept increasing the money supply to pay for domestic expenditure for some time; this was the driver of hyperinflation. After allowing this to go on for some time, they resolved the issue nicely with a currency reform.

Note that while this also eroded confidence in the government and the German economy and led to poverty and to social turmoil, it solved at least one problem for the government: Wartime bonds from the first world war were not an issue any more since they were officially worth practically nothing now. Also note that the government was under a lot of pressure internationally (French and Belgian troops occupied the Ruhr area when they temporarily ceased payments of war reparations) and domestically and may not have had any other choice than letting the hyperinflation take its course before they were able to resolve it.

No hyperinflation in Germany after World War 2

The economy of Nazi Germany was based on a Ponzi scheme. They again issued bonds, MEFO bills that were ostensibly bonds raised for a private entity ("Metallurgical research association") that never existed. This helped the government run a huge deficit to build up armaments for the upcoming war, while all this being off the record and under the radar of the international community. The effort was scheduled as a 4-year plan with the first bonds becoming due in 1938. The aggression against Czechoslovakia in 1938 was intended as the start of the war; it surprised the hell out of Hitler and everyone else that the international community simply allowed this to happen. The failure of the international community to respond allowed the German army some more time to prepare for the war, but it also brought the German economy to the brink of collapse, since, of course, they could not pay for the bonds that became due. The central bank president resigned and the bond holders were kind of forced to exchange the MEFO bonds against government bonds. In August 1939, they nevertheless saw the need to ration basic consumer goods. Note that this was before the start of the war and the invasion of Poland. Also note that this is the other possible way to react to an oversupply of money besides allowing inflation to happen (see above).

They were able to do this, since German society and economy was completely under their control by then. During the war, they further transformed the economy into what was practically a centrally planned economy similar to the ones in the Soviet Union and the east block states, even though it was privately owned and the individual firms were privately managed under government supervision. This economic system, labeled command capitalism allowed the Nazis to transform the economy completely into a war economy. Slave labor (war prisoners, concentration camp inmates, civilians from occupied countries) and what was pillaged from occupied countries (machinery, money reserves, raw materials at extremely low prices etc etc etc) was brought in as the economic needs of the war effort gradually increased. This intensified especially after the failure of the Blitzkrieg against the Soviet Union and after the US entered the war.

After the end of the war, the currency predictably collapsed. Since rationing remained in effect, the collapse did not lead to hyperinflation in the same way it did in 1923. However, the black market in Germany immediately after the war used (American) cigarettes as money, not the official currency. The following currency reform in West Germany had socialist characteristics (with small amounts per capita being exchanged 1:1, funds beyond a certain threshold being frozen and later cut by 70%) and was supported by massive financial support from the US. In East Germany, the economy was simply transformed into a socialist central planning economy which had price controls by design.

  • "What was pillaged" included direct values and all manners of forced payments or rates of exchange. I maybe wrong on this but currently I fear it might be read as if this is mostly about famous pictures etc. (I blame it on the movies) – LаngLаngС Feb 26 '18 at 20:48
  • 1
    @LangLangC I added some explanation. Your point with exchange rates is interesting. In Poland they had an official exchange rate that undervalued the German Reichsmark compared to the złoty of occupied Poland (2zł:1ℛℳ instead of 3-4zł:1ℛℳ). I am not certain to what degree it helps to have your currency undervalued in order to undercut prices in the international market in this case. They were able to force the Polish to sell and buy at prices they could dictate, and they were certainly not afraid to do so. – 0range Feb 26 '18 at 21:21
1

After WWI, Germany had to pay vast overseas debts, which had been imposed as reparations for the cost of the war, by the victors. The new government essentially printed money to pay for its programme and set off the hyperinflation. The destruction of the value of Germans' savings was one of the things that turned the population against the government, and made the rise of the Nazis possible.

During WWII, the Nazis controlled the economy almost completely. They really didn't want inflation to take off, because it would cost them popular support, and by controlling prices and supply, they avoided it, at least in the legal economy; the black market was another matter.

After WWII, there was considerable inflation although not hyperinflation: money only lost about 99% of its value. A new currency was set up, and the German economy was rebuilt on a sound basis, to the point that it dominates Europe today.

  • 2
    And there is that dreaded "printed money" – paper bills like greenbacks are insignificant. – Otherwise this A is not incorrect, but anything on "why", that is 'how' (did they control "it")? – LаngLаngС Feb 25 '18 at 21:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.