13

The flag of Iceland, shown below, is described blazon as "Azure, a cross gules fimbriated argent", indicating that the fimbriation is silver. Argentum means silver in Latin.

enter image description here

Does this mean that originally the flag was fimbriated in silver, or was it always white?

migrated from politics.stackexchange.com Sep 25 '18 at 21:27

This question came from our site for people interested in governments, policies, and political processes.

  • 5
    Downvote because lacks basic research over heraldry. – Bregalad Sep 26 '18 at 14:55
  • 1
    " is described blazon as" Downvote for uncited source. – Mark C. Wallace Oct 8 '18 at 14:07
57

Silver means white.

The art and science of classic European flag design is called "Heraldry". Classic heraldry refers to color as "Tincture". Tinctures are separated into 5 colors:

  • Azure (blue)
  • Gules (red)
  • Purpure (purple)
  • Sable (black)
  • Vert (green)

and 2 metals:

  • Or (yellow)
  • Argent (white)

In classic medieval sculpting artworks depicting heraldry (like a family crest on a wall), the two metals Or and Argent should be depicted with Gold- or Silver plating if possible. If material (or budget) don't permit, then one can resort to yellow or white paint. You can't silver-plate a flag (at least not with the techniques available in the medieval age), so a silver flag would be a white flag.

  • 17
    @TylerDurden In classic heraldry, there is no difference between white and silver. If you wonder if anyone ever seriously intended for people to manufacture flags from silver thread and fly them, then the answer is likely no. – Philipp Sep 20 '18 at 17:08
  • 9
    @TylerDurden England: "argent, a cross gules": en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of_England. Scotland: "Azure, a saltire argent": en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of_Scotland. The white stripes in the US arms are "argent." Argent just means white in the context of heraldic blazons. – phoog Sep 20 '18 at 17:14
  • 5
    @TylerDurden The Union Jack also begins “Azure,” the same as Scotland’s flag. No indication is given in heraldric blazon about the particular shade of blue—you can see that Scotland’s flag consistently uses a lighter shade than the Union Jack, but that’s not actually a part of the official specification (and if someone made “Azure, a saltire argent,” with the Union Jack shade, that would still be Scotland’s flag). The shades of colors, the choice of white vs. silver, was up to the artist and available materials, because creating consistent shades across different time and place was impossible. – KRyan Sep 20 '18 at 18:15
  • 3
    @phoog Yes, modern designs often vary in how strictly they hold to traditional requirements, some of which are no longer relevant with our superior ability to consistently represent various colors and designs. Croatia are not the only ones to use celeste as an alternate, lighter blue than azure, either. But Scotland doesn’t, and someone who wanted to claim Celeste, a saltire argent would almost-certainly not be taken seriously by anyone—using celeste may or may not be OK, but it definitely isn’t enough to differentiate it from the same design in azure (which is why some dislike it). – KRyan Sep 21 '18 at 16:03
  • 4
    One quibble: Heraldry is not primarily concerned with flag design, but with coats of arms: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coat_of_arms – jamesqf Sep 21 '18 at 18:06
13

No.

The Icelandic flag never had any actual silver colour in it and was never meant to contain any silver.

In the quote argent is meant to convey just white. It is used in an outdated and imprecise form of traditional descriptive language.

While it's true that:

The word for white in Latin is "albus", not argentum. Argentum means silver.

In heraldry the proper word for red is not rouge but gueules, which now designates as a French word the mouth of an animal. This is Medieval tradition, not modern linguistics.

The Icelandic flag has always been red, blue and white like snow. White, white alone, always white and nothing but white, the actual colour, not silver:

The civil national flag of Icelanders is blue as the sky with a snow-white cross, and a fiery-red cross inside the white cross. The arms of the cross extend to the edge of the flag, and their combined width is ​2⁄9, but the red cross ​1⁄9 of the combined width of the flag. The blue areas are right angled rectangles, the rectilinear surfaces are parallel and the outer rectilinear surfaces as wide as them, but twice the length. The dimensions between the width and length are 18:25.

The usage of the term argent is here mixing the terminology of vexillology with that of the older and more traditional heraldry. Vexillology is a sub-field of heraldry now, but does not really conform to all those overcome standards there.
Insisting to all what is white and meant to be white as argent?
Can be done, is not forbidden, but a bit outdated and pretentious when applied to flags instead of coat of arms –– and leads to confusion, as evidenced here.

Unlike the German flag that really has to be described as containing (ideally) gold the Icelandic one is properly just white like snow. (Compare the German flag again with that of Belgium to see the distinction).

As the above Wikipedia page states: Vexillology rarely distinguishes between gold and yellow; in heraldry, they are both Or. For the German flag, such a distinction is made: the color used in the flag is gold, not yellow. And for the Icelandic flag it is white.

In heraldry the tincture white is commonly described as argent

Metals
The metals are or and argent, representing gold and silver, respectively, although in practice they are often depicted as yellow and white.

Or (Ger. Gelb, Gold, or golden) –– derives its name from the Latin aurum, "gold". It may be depicted using either yellow or metallic gold, at the artist's discretion; "yellow" has no separate existence in heraldry, and is never used to represent any tincture other than or.

Argent (Ger. Weiß, Weiss, Silber, or silbern) –– is similarly derived from the Latin argentum, "silver". Although sometimes depicted as metallic silver or faint grey, it is more often represented by white, in part because of the tendency for silver paint to oxidize and darken over time, and in part because of the pleasing effect of white against a contrasting colour. Notwithstanding the widespread use of white for argent, some heraldic authorities have suggested the existence of white as a distinct heraldic colour.

So, in classical heraldic terms argent really always means silver, it's just that because of cost or material availability or some other restrictions they came to use white as an almost equivalent substitute. Thus paving the way for the synonymous quality of silver and white in heraldry. In modern heraldry white became also arguably a distinct colour.

With regard to the other metal, silver, or, as it is always termed, "argent", the same variation is found in the usage of silver and white in representing argent that we find in yellow and gold, though we find that the use of the actual metal (silver) in emblazonment does not occur to anything like the same extent as does the use of gold. Probably this is due to the practical difficulty that no one has yet discovered a silver medium which does not lose its colour. The use of aluminium was thought to have solved the difficulty, but even this loses its brilliancy, and probably its usage wall never be universally adopted. This is a pity, for the use of gold in emblazonments gives a brilliancy in effect to a collection of coat-armour which it is a pity cannot be extended by an equivalent usage of silver. The use of silver upon the patents at the College of Arms has been discontinued some centuries, though aluminium is still in use in Lyon Office. Argent is therefore usually represented either by leaving the surface untouched, or by the use of Chinese white. I believe I am the first heraldic writer to assert the existence of the heraldic colour of white in addition to the heraldic argent.
A. C. Fox-Davies: "A Complete Guide to Heraldry", TC & AC Black: London, 1909, p 70.

In modern flag design however there is now a clear distinction to observe between calling a colour silver or white, yellow or gold. As evidenced in the text of the Icelandic law for the flag: the Icelandic Flag is a modern design (it was officially described in Law No. 34, set out on 17 June 1944): Therefore, for Iceland this was always not the metallic silver of a knight in shining armour on his coat of arms, but the blinding white of the snow on that island.

  • The word for white in Latin is "albus", not argentum. Argentum means silver. – Tyler Durden Sep 20 '18 at 16:29
  • 14
    @TylerDurden Yep. And in heraldry the proper word for red is not rouge but gueules, which now designates as a French word the moth of an animal. This is Medieval tradition, not modern linguistics. – LаngLаngС Sep 20 '18 at 16:35
  • 4
    "Compare the German flag again with that of Belgium" - incidentally both seem to have inherited their colours from common source, but the German flag - in that form going back to the Hambach event and a fraternity - completely broke with heraldic rules, not only by using actual gold for what was only called gold, but supposed to be yellow, but also by having two colours (red and black) next to each other without a metal separation – Hagen von Eitzen Sep 21 '18 at 6:25
  • Oh, the German flag... the original was gold, the original (1848) description read "yellow" in article 1 and 3 but "gold" in article 2; today's official description is "gold", calling it "yellow" is considered slander, and the official RAL color for the third band is "rapeseed yellow". Fun. ;-) – DevSolar Sep 26 '18 at 11:10
  • @DevSolar Yeah, like the most famous facebook status? Since this is about Iceland I thought I'd get away reasonably with "ideally" and 'now'… Is RAL also defined for metal shields and plaques or only for dull substrates like fabric or paper? – LаngLаngС Sep 26 '18 at 11:20

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.