1

I was wondering if there ever was a genocidal act or massacre where people were thrown off a cliff?

I don't mean killed and then thrown off, I mean instances where people were thrown off and killed by the fall.

  • 20
    There's a significant difference between a massacre and a genocide. – Steve Bird Apr 9 at 20:17
  • 1
    Croatian Ustashe did something similar against Serb civilians : "In the summer of 1941, Ustashe militias and death squads burnt villages and killed thousands of civilian Serbs in the country-side in sadistic ways with various weapons and tools. Men, women, children were hacked to death, thrown alive into pits and down ravines, or set on fire in churches." en.wikipedia.org/wiki/… – rs.29 Apr 9 at 21:13
  • 1
    @agentprovocateur The suicides at Laderan Banadero and other places were neither a genocide nor a massacre. – sempaiscuba Apr 9 at 22:43
  • 4
    @ZomZ- welcome to Stack Exchange! Check out the Help Center for guidelines on asking questions. For example, what research have you done on this topic (Google searches, books, etc.)? – 米凯乐 Apr 9 at 23:28
  • 1
    @Greg ok. dont know why you're trying to explain it to me. lol. you should explain it to JMS's answer – agent provocateur Apr 11 at 17:24
5

Yes, in the Awa'uq Massacre, or Massacre of Refuge Rock.

In this episode Russians under fur magnate Grigorii Shelikhov fired on Koniag Alutiiq people (per Wikipedia, those of the Qik’rtarmiut Sugpiat tribe) massed atop the large rock. One source, Briutikov, is reported to have said that 500 were killed in their fall from the rock. Owen Matthews in his book "Glorious Misadventures" (p. 65) describes the account of another witness, Izmailov, who said that "probably many more" victims jumped or fell from the rock than were killed there.

3

7-800 soldiers were forced or pushed off of a 1000 foot cliff in one of the unification battles of Hawai'i. Wikipedia article

This was one of the last major battles of the campaign. The article details how the remains were discovered during construction 100 years later (in 1898).

1

One biography of Cervantes (he was prisoner in N. Africa, ~ 1575-80) tells the following:

In N. Africa (Algiers, I think) there were a high cliff from where slaves or unransomed prisoners were thrown to their deaths. In the cliff walls there were various kinds of large hooks and spikes embedded in the rock.

It was the masters' sport to bet on how and how quickly the slaves/prisoners would die. Some did not hit any hook and died instantly when hitting the stones in the sea floor; Some would be lacerated by some hook or metal spike and be torn in pieces during the fall; Some would get stuck in the hooks, sometimes taking hours to die, depending on how much they were hurt or bled. Some would be stuck in the hooks by their chains, being not really hurt, and thus would die by dehydration in a few days. Lots of variations to bet on!

'unransomed prisoners' means victims of Muslim piracy in the Mediterranean or Atlantic, who were not able to be ransomed or valuable as slaves (families or charitable orders would often pay their captors for their release, most famously the Mercedarians )

And it look like throwing them off a cliff is one of the 5 accepted ways to execute gays in Islamic jurisprudence, at least accordingly to Shaykh Hamza Sodagar and others. So the ISIS habit of throwing them from high buildings has precedents, after all. One Tunisian iman cites a hadith directly from Mohamed (see at 4:00): The Prophet Muhammad said: “Whoever you find engaged in sodomy – kill both the man who does it and the man to whom it is done.” But the same Tunisian also clarifies that throwing from a high place is the preferred method only for the Hanafi school, others prefer other methods.

  • The last paragraph would need more credible sources. If it was a jurisprudence, there would be official texts endorcing it. – Evargalo Jul 19 at 8:23
  • I added a source with claimed hadith, but it is quite easy to find more references, just google it. Jihad Watch has various entries quotes about this subject – Luiz Jul 19 at 23:41
-2

I don't know about cliff genocides - a very large cliff or a very small tribe would be necessary for a cliff genocide.

But cliff massacres are another story. If one agrees on the minimum number of persons for a massacre, one can find a few cliff massacres.

American Indians sometimes drove buffalo herds off cliffs, but I suppose that buffalo don't count for massacres.

I think that in the movies Solomon and Sheba (1959), and Taras Bulba (1962) feature battle tactics causing enemies to fall off cliffs, Trooper Hook (1957) begins with a cliff massacre, and Smoke signal (1955) has a one man cliff massacre. But those are fictional movies.

Many historical persons died from falls, deliberate or accidental.

Jan Masaryk (1886-1948) foreign minister of Czechoslovakia, jumped, fell, or was pushed to his death 10 March 1948.

On May 23, 1618, a crowd of Protestant leaders defenestrated two of the regents of Bohemia and their secretary out of a 70 foot high third story window in the Bohemian Chancery at Prague. They survived, but this led to the Thirty Years War.

On 30 July 1419, a pro Hussite crowd defenestrated the judge, the burgomaster, and 5 city council members from the New Town Hall in Prague. All seven died, and the Hussite Wars resulted.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defenestrations_of_Prague

In 1195 Alexios Angelus deposed, blinded, and imprisoned his brother Isaac II and became emperor Alexios III. Isaac II's son Alexios (c. 1182-1204) escaped from prison in 1201. In 1203 the Fourth Crusade attacked Constantinople, and Alexios III fled. Isaac Ii was restored to power and Alexios IV made his co emperor, but they were unable to pay the crusaders all that Alexios IV had promised. Alexios Doukas overthrew and murdered Alexios IV and Isaac II in January 1204 and became Emperor Alexios V.

The Crusaders captured Constantinople on 12 April 1204 and formed the so called "Latin Empire". In exile, Alexios III married his daughter to Alexios V, but later blinded him. Alexios IV was captured by the crusaders and executed in December 1204 by being thrown off the top of the Column of Theodosius.

Thee is a story about Henri Christophe, King of Haiti from 1811-1820, receiving a foreign envoy at his cliff top Citadelle Laferriere. According to the story he demonstrated the iron discipline of his troops by ordering a unit to march across the parade ground. When the troops reached the battlements over the cliffs they received no orders to stop, and so continued marching over the battlements and fell to their deaths.

If true, that story would be the best example of a "cliff massacre" I can think of.

  • More examples here. IIRC the Taliban also used this method in recent times. – Tomas By Apr 10 at 4:02
  • 3
    I don't think scenes from films can be presented as evidence. – RedSonja Apr 10 at 10:24
-3

I don't know if this counts or if mass suicides could be considered genocide. But reading the question all I could think of was WWII, Suicide Cliff and Bonzai Cliff in Saipan, where thousands of Japanese civilians ( women, children ) and soldiers threw themselves to their deaths rather than be captured by American forces.

Suicide Cliff
Japanese propaganda emphasized brutal treatment of Japanese such as American mutilation of Japanese war dead. Many Japanese feared the "American devils raping and devouring Japanese women and children." The precise number of suicides there is not known. One eyewitness said he saw “hundreds of bodies” below the cliff, while elsewhere, numbers in the thousands have been cited. A contemporary correspondent, praising their actions as "the finest act of the Shōwa period", described them as "the pride of Japanese women."[6]

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.