1

The term replica firearm has an imprecise meaning. It covers everything from functioning firearms that look like historical weapons to toys that simply have the appearance of an historical or contemporary firearm. I am not interested in modern airsoft or bb gun lookalikes.

I am interested in discovering if 'collector-grade' or 'museum-quality', 'non-firing' replica firearms were ever produced using the same materials and equipment employed for the actual firearms they replicate and sold to the general public.

I would also like to know which manufacturers did this, if any, what firearms were replicated in this manner, what time period they were produced (1900-20??), and which countries they were sold in.

A replica cannot fire or be made to fire. Otherwise it is a firearm regardless of its present state.Typically replicas have bores and chambers that will not accept any known cartridge. There may be other differences which prevent them from firing or being made to fire. I am interested in those differences as well. I can recall ads for near perfect replicas from the 70's, before the International Trade in Arms Agreement, and I wonder if they were actually made on the same equipment and used the same materials.

  • 2
    If a repllca is made using the same materials on the same equipment as the real firearm is it still a replica? If you take the firing pin out of a working weapon does that make it a replica? – KillingTime May 26 at 20:50
1

What you may be remembering might have been an ad similar to this one, from Boys' Life magazine, May 1970.

enter image description here

Note the text in the ad,

"Made of frangible zinc alloy, cannot be converted into an actual gun."

Since the original weapons were not made of frangible zinc alloy, it is unlikely that the same equipment could be used to manufacture both the original and the replicas. If the replica did use parts made on the original equipment, then it would be strong enough to be used as a firearm, and could be modified just by 'fixing' the modification or replacing a couple of parts that made it unfireable.

A little research led to the fact that that original replica company, Replica Models,Inc. is still in business, now under the name Collector's Armory, Ltd..

Update.

Since we have a little more info from comments about the question, there is a category of replica weapons which might be relevant here, blank-firing replicas. A document here has information on 'illicit' conversions, focusing on three common types:

  1. The alteration of a replica firearm to fire live ammunition was the most commonly recognized form of conversion.

  2. The reactivation of a deactivated firearm is occasionally referred to as a conversion. A deactivated firearm is a genuine firearm which has been rendered inoperable (i.e. incapable of expelling a projectile). This form of conversion involves reversing the deactivation process to enable the item to once again fire a projectile.

  3. A semi-automatic firearm modified to have fully automatic (select-fire) firing capacity is the third alteration occasionally referred to as a conversion.

Since the question seems to be focusing on this possible conversion process, the above source has a table detailing 27 various blank-firing replica weapons which can possibly be converted to firing weapons.

If the blank firing replica simulates fully-automatic fire, then theoretically some its parts might be usable to convert the 'action' of a 'real' semi-auto weapon into full-auto. The feasibility of this, and the source or originality of the internal parts used, would have to be addressed on a case-by-case basis. As you can see from the table in the pdf, and the retail page linked below, the list of replicas to individually evaluate would be quite extensive.

Incidentally, the retailer mentioned above, Collector's Armory, has a section selling blank guns, including semi-autos and fully automatic replicas.

These authentic Blank Guns are an ideal resource for training, theatrical props, and re-enactment purposes. Many of these pieces are the same prop guns used by filmmakers in Hollywood and the world over.

  • I am aware of the pot metal reproductions. This is not what I am investigating. I have run across a reference in a law case which refers to the possibility of removing the fire control group from a replica firearm, in the specific case a replica Uzi, and using this to convert an Uzi carbine into a full auto weapon. I found this idea rather far fetched but this statement formed part of a judgment issued by a Canadian court. I infer that this statement is based upon some fact as it is used in a criminal conviction. I am trying to find out if such a thing was ever possible. – James B. Byrne May 28 at 0:30
  • 6
    @JamesB.Byrne That information should be in the question. – Mark C. Wallace May 28 at 0:38
  • @James B. Byrne: Any good gunsmith, and many amateur mechanics, could convert a semi-automatic carbine to full auto. I've even know it to happen through wear. (With the Chinese SKS clone of the AK-47.) – jamesqf May 28 at 17:57
  • @jamesqf: True, but irrelevant. I am trying to find out if near firearm quality replicas were ever produced; and whether or not these replicas were ever manufactured in the same manner as the firearms themselves. – James B. Byrne May 29 at 13:06

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.