2

Why did the U.S. place an arms embargo on all belligerents in the 1948 Arab-Israeli war? My understanding is that it hindered Israel more and forced them to buy weapons from Czechoslovakia. Most people don't know this, but the Soviet Union was the first country to help the nascent Jewish state. https://www.haaretz.com/1.4904990

  • 3
    I'm not versed in this topic, but Shlomo Slonim argues in "The 1948 American Embargo on Arms to Palestine" that the State Department was against the Partition of Palestine (seemingly out of preference for a 1 state solution?) and believed that an arms embargo against Israel would prevent the partition from happening and then grew into a a self-reinforcing "policy" after the State of Israel was created. The author clearly has a certain dog in the race though, so I wouldn't necessarily take this at face value. – Semaphore Nov 4 at 9:48
  • Actually, the first state to help the nascent Jewish state was the British Empire by authorising the notorious Balfour Declaration. – Mozibur Ullah Nov 4 at 22:18
  • @Semaphore... Actually the United States was one of the primary authors of Resolution 181(ii) in Nov of 1947, and both France and Liberia reported the United States threatened to withhold economic aid if they did not vote for Partition, and of coarse the United States also voted for the resolution. – JMS Nov 5 at 1:20
2

Question: Why did the U.S. place an arms embargo on all belligerents in the 1948 Arab-Israeli war?

Answer:

The United States cut off weapons shipments to the region 5 months prior to the hostilities breaking out Dec 5, 1947. It did so because the United States a few days earlier had just helped negotiate a partition agreement UN Resolution 181(III) Nov 29th 1947 in the General Assemble. Part of that resolution called for the UN Security Council to secure the peace. This coincided with the US's discontinuing export licenses of arms December 5 not a formal embargo.

Now in addition to the US discontinuing export licensing of arms in 1947, The United States also participated in the United Nations arms embargo in June of 1948. This embargo coincided with a UN negotiated cease fire in the conflict and the embargo was designed to ensure neither side used the cease fire to improve their strategic position.

The US primary motivation in it's action in 1947 - 49 was to secure a negotiated peace in the ME through the United Nations and then directly after hostilities began. When War broke out the US's efforts focused on brokering an Armistice; which the American Ralph Bunche successfully negotiated in 1949, after the assassination of his predecessor, for which Mr. Bunche received the Nobel Peace Prize in 1950.

Timelne

  • Nov 29, 1947 the UN General Assembly adopts a partition plan Resolution 181 (II)
  • Dec 5th, 1947 The United States discontinued the export licensing of arms to Palestine and neighboring Countries as part of Resolution (ll).
  • May 14, 1948 Israel declares itself a state.
  • May 14, 1948 The United States becomes the first country to recognize Israel, about 2 hours after it's declaration
  • May 15 1948 The Arab Israeli war begins
  • June 11 – July 9 1948 UN Embargo of Arms to Palestine and Neighboring Countries coincides with a UN negotiated cease fire.
  • Sept 17, 1948 Swedish UN Envoy Folke Bernadotte assassinated in Jerusalem by members of the underground Jewish Lehi group, which was led by Yitzhak Shamir as Bennadotte was negotiating an armistice agreement.
  • March 10 1949 The Arab Israeli War ends..
  • 1950 - The African American Ralph Bunche receives Nobel Peace Prize in 1950 for continuing Folke Bernadotte's work and successfully negotiating the 1949 Armistice.
  • Thank you for answering! – user27343 Nov 5 at 3:44
2

This is quite complicated but from the information I found online it looks like the US in 1947 had two reasons for having an embargo. This is from an article called Arms and Influence: British arms policy and the decline of British influence in the Middle East, 1948-49

Following World War II, the US government adopted a policy of providing very limited arms supplies to the Middle East, usually small quantities for internal security purposes only.30 During the course of Anglo-American military talks, known as the “Pentagon Talks”31 held in October and November 1947, the United States acknowledged Britain’s dominate influence in the Middle East.32 In November 1947 the State Department decided to impose a unilateral arms embargo on the Middle East to prevent the Arabs using “arms of US origin against Jews, or Jews using them against Arabs” to prevent bitter recrimination against the USA.33 The embargo became public policy after the State Department issued a statement on 5 December 1947, which included a detailed breakdown of the inconsequential US arms supplies to the region.34

So it looks like the US didn't want to take sides and wanted to not get involved as the British were more established in the region. And the US was also worried about the future and oil. There's anotherarticle called U.S. Policy in Israel/Palestine, 1948: The Forgotten History which says more about this, and that there were also disagreements in the US adminstration about what to do.

  • 1
    At the time the US was the far and away the world's biggest oil producer, so this was likely a period when their view of that part of the world was much less influenced by its oil reserves than it is today. – T.E.D. Nov 4 at 13:38

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.