3

During World War I, Austrohungarian authorities ran a so-called internment camp in Thalerhof (close to Graz in modern Austria). According to Encyclopedia of Ukraine

The first 2,000 prisoners at Thalerhof, the largest camp, arrived on 4 September 1914, and by late 1914 the camp held 8,000 prisoners, 5,700 of them Ukrainians. In November 1916 it had 2,717 prisoners; 85 percent were Ukrainian, 76 percent were peasants, and 7 percent were Greek Catholic priests. Between 1914 and 1916, 14,000 internees passed through the camp. Its strict regime, the authorities' arbitrary actions, the starvation rations, the extremely unsanitary conditions, and various outbreaks of typhus and other diseases resulted in a high mortality rate among the prisoners. Although 1,767 deaths were registered, it can be assumed that there were many more; between 17 January and 31 March 1915 alone, 524 people died.

Were there institutions with similar levels of mortality in Europe prior to Thalerhof? In other words, can Thalerhof be considered the first concentration camp in Europe (putting aside the harmless sounding "internment camp" name)?

If not, what was the first concentration camp in Europe?

Results of my research: There were concentration camps run by the British at the beginning of the 20th century:

A few years later during the Boer War, in what is modern South Africa, Britain's General Kitchener used "concentration camps" to contain hostile civilians. These were mainly Boers, whites of Dutch origin. Blacks were also subjected to this treatment. Some 28,000 whites and 14,000 blacks died in Kitchener's camps. The tactic played a major part in winning the war for the empire.

Source

The article does not say whether or not those concentration camps were located in Britain or South Africa.

Prior to that, there were concentration camps in Cuba, invented by the Spanish general Weyler.

There is a question about concentration camps in general, but it does not mention any European, pre 1930-s concentration camps.

Update 1: My definition of concentration camp:

An institution where civilians (no prisoners of war) are involuntarily kept under conditions that lead to a significantly higher mortality rate than outside that institution in that region.

By this definition, if

  • the mortality rate of Thalerhof inmates was significantly higher than the average mortality in Western Ukraine in 1914 and
  • its inmates were put their against their will (i. e. would not go there if they had the choice),

then Thalerhof is a concentration camp.

  • 2
    As pointed out in the other question you mentioned, the answer to this is going to depend to a large extend on your definition of the term "concentration camp". Wikipedia has a list of List of concentration and internment camps that may be of interest here. – sempaiscuba Dec 11 '19 at 14:04
  • @sempaiscuba Thanks. I added my definition in update 1. – Franz Drollig Dec 11 '19 at 14:09
  • An example that comes to mind are British prison ships in the 18th century. They would seem to meet your definition. But that's not an entirely reasonable definition of a concentration camp, what's new about the Boer camps is the sheer scale of internment and the fact that people kept there were not individually convicted of anything (they were in South Africa, as a quick look at Wikipedia would confirm). – Relaxed Dec 11 '19 at 18:04
  • 1
    The mortality rate is a questionable part of the definition: in camps, the mortality rate might have been much higher than in Ukraina - in peacetime, but hard to compare to alternatives in wartime. Civilians trapped under siege (Leningrad, Sarajevo) or between frontlines (Okinawa) or simply living under occupation (Hunger Winter in Neitherland) can have a very high mortality rate, too. I think putting civilians by military force for an indefinite time in a camp (based on ethnicity or other non-criminal reasons?) already covers much what you are looking for. – Greg Dec 12 '19 at 3:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.