# How was the first carpenter's square made?

A "square" is a tool, typically L or triangle shaped, that gives a craftsperson a quick and accurate 90° angle to use as a baseline in many important trades.

It's easy to find a right angle if you already have a square, but how was the first square made? How can someone create a right angle tool "from scratch"?

• With todays knowledge, its easy to make a right angle from scratch, swing arcs at the 3,4 and 5 proportions. Feb 22, 2020 at 16:51
• This reads more like mathematics than history. Feb 22, 2020 at 17:33
• @DJClayworth It's a question about the history of mathematics. I think I'm much more likely to find an answer to such a question here in history.se than in math.se. Feb 22, 2020 at 17:48
• Personally, I'd say it's a question about history, so it's on-topic here. Of course it would also be on-topic on History of Science and Mathematics:SE. Feb 22, 2020 at 18:30
• You don't need to read Euclid for this. Just any beginners textbook of Geometry. A right angle can be constructed using a simple tool which is called a "pair of compasses".
– Alex
Feb 23, 2020 at 2:28

Proposition 11 of Book I of Euclid's Elements (circa 300 B.C. in Alexandria Egypt) is:

To draw a straight line at right angles to a given straight line from a given point on it.

Note that Euclid's contribution to geometry is one of compilation, and of constructing a formal axiomatic system for plane geometry. Most if not all the work was well known long before Euclid, and for the early propositions of Book I this "prior time period" measures in centuries if not millennia. The first square is thus so far back in antiquity as to be most likely impossible to date.

It is certainly true that the ancient Egyptians were quite able to construct right angles well before the construction of the earliest pyramids, and most likely were also aware of the Pythagorean triple (3,4,5).

### First Propositions of Book I

The Babylonian clay table known as Plimpton 322, from about 1800 B.C.E., contains a list of Pythagorean Triples:

In each row, the number in the second column can be interpreted as the shorter side s of a right triangle, and the number in the third column can be interpreted as the hypotenuse d of the triangle. In all cases, the longer side l is also an integer, making s and d two elements of a Pythagorean triple

• Fascinating! I understand most of this, however I'm not sure how someone could reliably draw the equilateral triangle FDE. Is that part of a different proposition? EDIT: nevermind, found it! Book 1 Proposition 1. Feb 22, 2020 at 17:53
• @PinkSweetener: Proposition 1: From the intersection of arcs (of radius equal to the given base) drawn on the endpoints of the given base. Connect that intersection to the endpoints. Feb 22, 2020 at 17:59

How can someone create a right angle tool "from scratch"?

### Mathematics

If you can create a straight edge, you can construct a square. You don't need to know any trigonometry beyond the idea that two right-angles make a straight line.

### 1. Produce a straight edge

Generally, to the level of accuracy needed for woodworking (joinery etc) you can tell whether an edge is straight by looking along it with your unaided eye. You can construct tools such as long wooden "jointer" planes that aid in the production of straight edges on planks but the general technique is not dependent on having a straight tool already. If your eyesight isn't good enough you lay your straight edge on another flattish plank and draw a line using the straight edge, then you rotate the straight edge 180, align its ends to the first line and draw a second line over the first. If the edge isn't straight the two lines will visibly diverge at one or more places in between the aligned ends.

This is a simpler case than creating a perfectly flat two dimensional surface of the sort that precision machinists use to check their work and their tools. A typical high-precision granite surface plate is flattened by nothing more complex than rubbing two lumps of granite together. Quickly measuring the flatness to high accuracy may require precision optics but this isn't really a task that requires powered machinery or electronics. It doesn't require a reference surface.

### 2. Use the straight edge to produce a square.

You can then create an L-shaped "square" by eye and check it against your straight edge. The method is to lay one arm of your square against the straight edge of a plank and mark a first perpendicular line across the plank along the other edge of the square, you then flip the square over, align the square where the line meets the straight-edge and draw a second perpendicular line across the plank, this will likely form a narrow V because your square is not exactly right. You can see how far out your square is and make appropriate adjustments, repeating the process until you are no longer able to see any divergence in your perpendiculars.

### Notes

Current day carpenters and machinists routinely use these methods to check squares.