I eventually found this lady Dr. Lori, who has a really great youtube channel on all types of antiques.
I went to her site to pay for an appraisal. She does free appraisals if the value of your item is less than $60
I just submitted my bowl - we'll see https://www.drloriv.com/
So Dr. Lori got back to me with her report and it turns out that it's an authentic piece! It's pretty common so not worth a ton but hey, better to have old crap not worth much than fake crap not worth much I guess.
Description: A ceramic decorated attributed Pre-Columbian bowl with a
large loss area at the rim featuring concentric circular decoration
that unites the decoration of the rim of the bowl to its center with a
repeating pattern of four-legged (woodland) small animalistic figures
with exaggerated eye in profile, large head, and curly tail in the
PreColumbian Narino style. Based on the photographs provided by the
owner, the piece is in good, stable condition with a clean break at
the loss area of the rim and the remainder of the bowl shows signs of
age and condition traits consistent with age and appropriate wear.
Size: 3 x 6 inches
Evaluation with Comparable sales records: In my opinion and based on
the image and information that was provided to me by the client, this
piece provides strong evidence to a typical piece(s) of its type by
the artist or firm or comparable pieces by comparable artists or firms
of the period, status, and manner. The listing below is not an
endorsement of any of the sales outlets listed.
Comparable sales records (shown below) reflect recorded sales of
similar works in type, style, execution or other aspects, including:
Pre-Columbian, Ecuador/Colombia, Narino, circa 1200 CE. Hand built
bowl, ceramic, shallow, negative resist decoration on the interior,
zoomorphic motif with staring eyes, star motif, approximately 9 x 3
inches, Artemis Gallery, Louisville, CO, $275.00
Your Item(s): The evaluation is based on the appraiser’s opinion per
objects evaluated. In the opinion of this appraiser, upon
authentication, and based on the information and images provided by
the client, the appraised value range for the original work(s) of art
or vintage or antique object(s) presented by the client is $150.00 in
its current condition, retail value based on the current market,
condition, pedigree or provenance, history of the object and the
original owner, location, and other factors.