34

Java is the most populated island in the world, with 141.4 million residents. However, it is smaller than many other islands. There are other islands, such as Madagascar, Borneo, Sulawesi, Honshu (Japan), and Sri Lanka, which I would expect to have a higher population than Java. There are many other islands which have tropical climates and similar terrain. Why don't they have a larger population? In addition, Java was ruled by the Dutch, who treated their colonies horribly and tortured natives. Why do they have such a large population?

(Edit): What geographical factors made it more likely for wet rice cultivation to be done in Java compared to other islands?

  • 5
    Quick upvote from me for asking the question I avoided a day or two ago (but still wondered about) in answering another question. – T.E.D. Jun 3 at 21:17
  • 10
    Japan is not tropical, neither a very friendly place geographically. Most part is uninhabitable, with steep mountains and frequently flooding valleys. – Greg Jun 4 at 6:11
  • 1
    Not sure if this is an acceptable reference for history and what you're looking for, but as an Indonesian, the first thing that came to my mind is the late and difficulty of population control.. – Andrew T. Jun 5 at 6:19
  • 4
    Not surprised it's so populated, considering 3 Billion Devices Run Java. – At0mic Jun 6 at 16:07
32

One important factor is soil fertility:

Java’s soils are very fertile because of periodic enrichment by volcanic ash.

In contrast, with the two nearby large Indonesian islands of Borneo (shared with Brunei and Malaysia) and Sumatra:

Borneo, the world’s third largest island, has exemplary rainforest soils: shallow and nutrient poor. The abundance of rain in these ancient ecosystems has leached the soil for millions of years.

In contrast to overpopulated Java the neighbouring island of Sumatra still provides huge unused land reserves. However, by far not all of these reserves can be regarded as real agricultural potentials, e.g. for resettlement projects. Especially the poor soils often prove an agricultural handicap. Besides soil fertility the existing vegetation has to be considered. Thus, for example, the so called "alang alang grass savannas" in general show better potentialities than forest areas, while most of the swamps prove rather unsuitable for agricultural development.

(I don't think it makes sense to compare Java with islands like Honshu or Madagascar that are in other countries with entirely different histories.)

| improve this answer | |
24

The most fundamental reason with respect to other parts of tropical Asia is the earlier adoption of wet rice cultivation in Java. Grigg points out that the only places in Asia that had greater population densities in the late 19th century were China and Japan. Wet rice is just an amazingly productive form of agriculture, especially by traditional standards, before the age of synthetic fertilizers.

Japan is a different case. It is only recently that Java's population has surpassed Japan's, and that is due to Japan having some of the lowest fertility rates in the world. Java is still at an earlier stage of its demographic transition, but over time its population growth is gradually slowing down.

| improve this answer | |
  • 2
    What geographical factors made Java have a higher chance of adopting wet rice cultivation? – Manu Jun 3 at 22:14
  • 1
    @Manu Not sure, but Grigg says that it was probably brought by immigrants from mainland SE Asia. I'm not sure if and when they settled other islands. He also mentions the "small basins of volcanic soils in central in eastern Java" which may have been unique. – Brian Z Jun 4 at 2:10
2

In Clifford Geertz' classic volume Agricultural Involution: the Processes of Ecological Change in Indonesia (1963), the author argues that the Javanese form of wet rice cultivation has a very high potential to "absorb labor". While Geertz' view has been criticized – for an enlightening discussion see Wood (2020), Chapter 6 (preview available on Google Books) – it is a good starting point towards answering your question. Wood writes:

It is fundamental to Geertz's view that different agricultural systems have different capacities for labor absorption and involution. According to Geertz, wet rice farming as practiced in East and Southeast Asia probalby has the highest capacity to absorb labor of any form of traditional agriculture...

Wood, (2020).

Thus, the particular attributes of wet rice farming systems in the tropics and subtropics allow these systems to support, and indeed in the views of some authors demand, high population densities. High density, high intensity wet rice systems are found throughout south and southeastern Asia.

However, as other responders to this question remarked, the properties of the physical environment are also critical factors in the potential for a high density wet rice system. Growing season temperature and rainfall will influence potential productivity, but in tropical and temperate monsoon Asia, soil fertility is probably more important. So the best examples of high density rice systems are found not just in the young, fertile volcanic soils of Java, but also along the major river valleys and deltas of the region, e.g., Mekong, Red, Chao Phraya, Irrawaddy, Pearl, Yangtze, Ganges, and in the fertile but narrow volcanic valleys of Japan. As noted above, the other islands you mention:

Madagascar, Borneo, Sulawesi, Honshu (Japan), and Sri Lanka

are characterized by older and more complex geology with significantly less fertile soils, and in the case of Japan, substantial areas with cool to cold temperate climate where rice agriculture would have been limited to a single crop per year, if at all.

| improve this answer | |
  • This is a good, very well written, answer. However, some additional emphasis on how this would have affected Java (say in comparison to a place which didn't use these technologies) would be helpful. – gktscrk Jun 7 at 7:17

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.