0

Whenever I look up how long it took for a blacksmith to certain tools or weapons, I just get information on forging swords. Let's say a peasant is trying to make his scythe efficient for self-defense or fighting an army and takes it to a blacksmith to temporarily turn it into a war scythe. How long would this take?

  • 8
    What's your definition of a 'war scythe'? Scythes are not well suited to warfare and are used as ad-hoc weapons when nothing else is available. While they might have a certain 'grim reaper' factor working for them, they would lose out to a simpler spear almost every time on the battlefield. – Steve Bird Aug 9 at 11:55
  • @SteveBird - While that's not wrong, they were in fact A Thing, and it looks like some blacksmiths did make them. – T.E.D. Aug 9 at 14:10
  • 1
    @T.E.D. That's why I asked what their definition of a war scythe was. The OP seemed to be talking about converting a farmer's scythe on a temporary basis while the one you linked to says "the war scythe is otherwise unrelated to agricultural tools and is a purpose-built infantry melee weapon". – Steve Bird Aug 9 at 14:27
  • @SteveBird - It does say that at the top. However, much of the text below talks about Polish peasants using them during multiple uprisings, which sounds to me a lot like farming implements being converted. That much could probably use clarification, but it seems safe to assume from the text the OP is talking about repurposed farm implements. – T.E.D. Aug 9 at 14:45
3

As an amateur blacksmith I can 'educated guess' based on the link in the comment provided by T.E.D.

The first five illustrations appear to show how an agricultural scythe would be converted for 'military' use. The attachment of the blade needs to be converted from horizontal to vertical since the weapon will be used for thrusting and chopping. The blade attachment would have to be similar to a swords 'tang' since there is not enough material to make a socket (which would be a better method). The third illustration shows additional reinforcement around the attachment point to strengthen it. The fourth and fifth illustrations show separating a portion of a heavy scythe blade and converting it to a forward thrusting spike. The blades from the first few illustrations are 'shallow' enough to not need this.

If you assume the blacksmith had the straight wooden pole and the additional materials for reinforcing the attachment already available the time to convert the tool would be on the order of four to six hours. The actual forging time would be at most 30 - 60 minutes for someone of a journeyman's level of experience. The majority of the time is taking the tool apart and then fitting the shaft to the blade, reinforcing it, etc.

Now a grain type scythe is not a particularly heavy bladed tool. If you tried to use a converted scythe against armored foes you wouldn't do much damage with a chop. You are better off trying to kill/injure the horse they are riding on or sticking to 'hedgehog' or phalanx type maneuvers (which farmers are not trained in so good luck).

| improve this answer | |
  • Am I right in thinking that this would, in effect, be a one-way conversion? (So that once done, you wouldn't easily be able to swap the blade back to it's old agricultural use.) – Steve Bird Aug 9 at 19:05
  • A Smith could again forge the tang of the straight blade back to a 90 degree corner but it certainly would be a weaker joint. – Matt Balent Aug 10 at 20:10

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.