Assuming a smith from the Hellenistic era of ancient Greece was given a lump of metal (specifically a gold alloy) and asked to produce more of the same kind of alloy, what methods would they have available to determine what metals make up that alloy, if any?
1How accurate? Remember that the ancients had no knowledge of elements as we now understand them, each a pure substances composed of atoms all with the same number of protons in the nucleus but possibly varying numbers of nuclear neutrons and "orbital" electrons. What alloying metals, as pure silver, pure gold, pure mercury, pure tin and pure copper would certainly have been known to the ancients, but other elements, both metals and not, would not have been known.– Pieter GeerkensNov 18, 2020 at 20:28
Welcome to History:Stack Exchange. Thank you for your question; please consider revising it to be more in line with our community expectations. Like many other stacks, we expect questions to provide evidence of prior research. That helps us to understand the question, and avoids our repeating work you've already done. Our help center, and other stacks provide additional resources to assist with revisions.– MCW ♦Nov 18, 2020 at 20:55
Yes, for limited applications.
Archimedes's famous "Eureka!" moment stems from being tasked with determining if a crown was made of pure gold or if some silver had been mixed in. The density of gold was known, so he could confirm the gold's purity from its density. The crown's weight was easy enough to measure, but he needed to know the volume of the very irregularly shaped crown to confirm its density. He got the idea of using water displacement to determine volume and the rest is history. The bit about the bathtub is anecdotal.
Using this idea, a jeweler could potentially reverse this process by forming a hypothesis about what alloys were in use, such as "I think this is a gold and silver alloy" and determine the percentages by checking the density and doing a little math. However, I do not have any evidence this was done.
For those interested, here's the math using modern algebra. The Greeks would have done this using geometry.
The total density of the object is the densities of the individual alloys times their percentages in the object.
d = d1*p1 + d2*p2
The percentages must add up to 100% (assuming only two alloys) so the first percentage can be expressed in terms of the second percentage.
1 = p1 + p2 p1 = 1 - p2 d = d1*(1 - p2) + d2*p2
And a formula to determine the second percentage can be derived.
d = d1 - d1*p2 + d2*p2 d - d1 = d2*p2 - d1*p2 d - d1 = p2(d2 - d1) (d - d1)/(d2 - d1) = p2
Plug in the densities of the object and the densities of your two alloys and you get the percentage of the 2nd alloy. Then the percentage of the 1st alloy is 1 - p2.
3You can easily calculate the proportion of each alloy if there are two of them and you know which ones they are (plus their densities in pure form, of course, but that would be fixed documentation). If you doubt if they mixed silver or copper, you will end up with two different proportions, but not know which is the one in the object you have (although in a few cases you would end up with an impossible solution and you know you can discard that) even more options if there are more candidate elements, or more than two components.– ÁngelNov 18, 2020 at 23:23
Archimedes was not exactly a "smith" :-)– AlexNov 19, 2020 at 14:31