27

In Anne Applebaum's recent book Iron Curtain: The Crushing of Eastern Europe 1944-1956 she claims the USSR supported the new state of Israel and states "Stalin believed Israel would quickly join the communist camp".

She doesn't cite any references for this, but is it true? And if so, what grounds were there for Stalin believing Israel would align itself with the Soviet Union?

  • 2
    Given the nature of much of the people around Ben Gurion, as well as Stalin's own mindset, it wouldn't surprise me in the least, but I know of no written record of Stalin ever stating so publicly. – jwenting Jun 6 '13 at 6:36
  • 3
    This excellent question is quite difficult to answer. @Drux and jwenting correctly point out that the Labor Party was a left one and had considerable respect for the USSR at the time. However, they were not quite the usual Stalinist cadre-fodder: (a) they were as Zionist as Socialist (b) they were not very radical, much more like social democrats than like communists. On the other hand there was a bona fide communist party and a more left radical party, Mapam, who looked much more amenable to communist plans. So perhaps Stalin was counting on them taking power later and becoming his stooges. – Felix Goldberg Jun 6 '13 at 12:26
  • 2
    @FelixGoldberg and don't forget that the Kibutzim project, which was initially intended to be the way all of Israel was to be organised (as a series of semi-independent communes) was very similar to the Soviet kolchoze/sovchoze system of communal farming and industry. Wouldn't surprise me at all if the Soviets heard about that plan and interpreted it as being an intent on creating a Soviet style state from the ground up. – jwenting Jun 6 '13 at 14:06
  • 2
    @jwenting: Very possible! Of course, there was one crucial difference between a Kibbutz and a kolchoze - memebership in the former was voluntary, whereas in the latter it was at gunpoint. But such differences could have escaped Stalin... – Felix Goldberg Jun 6 '13 at 14:22
  • 2
    @FelixGoldberg - most of early Zionists were quite hard left, Labor was just one manifestation of that. – DVK Jun 7 '13 at 16:30
21
  1. It is clear that Stalin supported the creation of Israel. From the Wiki:

    For Soviet foreign policy decision-makers, pragmatism took precedence over ideology. Without changing its official anti-Zionist stance, from late 1944, until 1948 and even later, Joseph Stalin adopted a pro-Zionist foreign policy, apparently believing that the new country would be socialist and would accelerate the decline of British influence in the Middle East.[cite: Paul Johnson, A History of the Jews (1987) p.527]

    On May 17, 1948, three days after Israel declared independence, the Soviet Union legally recognized it de jure, becoming the first country to grant de jure recognition to the Jewish state..In addition to the diplomatic support, arms from Czechoslovakia, part of the Soviet bloc, were crucial to Israel in the 1948 Arab-Israeli War.

    It's quite clear that this would NOT have happened had Stalin disagreed.

  2. As far as " what grounds were there for Stalin believing Israel would align itself with the Soviet Union":

    • as the commenters noted, most of the early Zionists and founders of Israel were politically quite left and socialist-bent. I consider this fact to be too well known and trivial to bother with sites, but if you wish I'll add them. Ex: [1].

    • Also, at the time, British and the West in general started swinging towards being more pro-Arab due to geopolitical concerns, notably oil (Lawrence of Arabia being a good example; and British resistance to the creation of Israel despite Balfour commitments being another example). As such, Israel would be a natural counterweight for Stalin to extend his influence in Near East, the same way United States was using Israel once the geopolitical alignments reversed themselves in 1970s when Arab states became Soviet clients and Israel American one.

  • 1
    Being "left and socialist-bent" is a far cry from toeing the Moscow line and the latter was all that mattered to Stalin. – sds Apr 14 '15 at 11:14
  • 2
    This is quite a shocker for me. It begs the question of exactly how the "swap", if I may call it that, occurred, because not long after this: Israel started getting western assistance making nuclear reactors, and USSR started supporting Syria, Afghanistan, and other Mideast and North Africa areas. – DrZ214 Aug 4 '15 at 6:12
  • 2
    +1 for pointing out that pragmatism is an important factor (if not most important) over naive ideas about ideology based friendship: having good relationship with Israel is a chance to get a influence in the region and weaken the Western influence. – Greg Jan 1 '16 at 12:28
8

Stalin was an ideologue, but not a very rigid one, and he was not an idiot.

He supported Israel because it was a thorn in the side of the British Empire (and its Arab relationships), not because the Zionists were left wing.

After all, left wing or right wing, anyone who did not toe the Moscow's line precisely was an enemy (cf Tito-Stalin Split). Stalin knew full well that people neither join the communist camp nor enter the prison camp voluntarily, and did not expect Israel to do so; and he did not have the resources to turn Israel into another Poland or Romania.

  • 1
    @Oldcat: nope. Emigration means loss of human material. Communists never encouraged that, they just sent the undesirables to labor camps. – sds Jul 23 '14 at 21:52
  • 2
    @Oldcat: emigration was VERY strongly discouraged. Otherwise half the country would have left. – sds Jul 23 '14 at 22:06
  • 1
    So was being Jewish. – Oldcat Jul 23 '14 at 22:09
  • 3
    @Oldcat - given that Stalin prepared to send a large chunk of Jews to Siberia in 1950s (see "Delo vrachei"), sds's comment is on the nose. Stalin needed Israel as a solution to USSR's "jewish problem" like a cow needs wheels. – DVK Jul 24 '14 at 15:27
  • 2
    Of this list, only Cuba was a member of the "communist camp" (i.e., toed the Moscow line), and Cuba received a lot of money (in the form of inflated sugar prices vs depressed oil prices). It goes without saying that all 4 brutally suppressed all dissent, so their people were not in the "camp" voluntarily. – sds Apr 14 '15 at 11:12
0

Stalin probably didn't believe that Israel would go "Communist," because there was no ideological connection between Communism and Zionism (except that a few people were in both camps).

Stalin probably believed that Israel could become his "catspaw" in the Middle East. The reasoning would be "the enemy of my enemy is my friend."

Stalin did not treat Jews particularly well in the Soviet Union. For all that, the Soviet Union deserves a lot of credit for the defeat of Nazi Germany, the persecutor of the Jews. Stalin was hoping that some of that "credit" would "rub off" on Jews and Israelis.

Stalin and the Soviet Union feared the Moslems, particularly the Arabs. The Israelis were the natural enemies of the Arabs. Stalin hoped (with reason) that the Israelis could keep the Arabs tied up on the Middle East, diminishing their threat to the Soviet Union.

Basically, there was some reason to hope that the Soviet Union and Israel could become "fellow travelers," not "fellow ideologues."

-1

Maybe Stalin misoverestimated some things: 1-Jewish gratitude for the fact that it was the Red Army that defeated Hitler thereby saving their bacon, so to speak

2-Jewish powerand influence in the United States Not that it isn't and wasn't considerable, but deliver the US to him? Not even had they wished!

I read a theory that holds that Stalin thought he had a deal with the Jews- a Jewish state in Palestine for a Communist one in North America.

.

Some of the information contained in this post requires additional references. Please edit to add citations to reliable sources that support the assertions made here. Unsourced material may be disputed or deleted.

  • 2
    @MarkC.Wallace - I've been wrong before, but this looks like a legit attempt to answer the question to me. However, it could be sourced better. I'll add a note to that effect. – T.E.D. Jun 27 '17 at 19:41
-3

Marxism and Communism were invented by people of the Jewish tribe. I use the word 'tribe' instead of Jewish 'faith' since atheism would contradict the tenants of Judaic faith so a Jewish atheist may be an oxymoron. Karl Marx, the co-author of Das Capital and Communist Manifesto was of Jewish ancestry with both his maternal and paternal grandfathers being rabbis. Leon Trotsky, whose original name was Lev Davidovich Bronstein, was born from Jewish parents.

Karl Marx formed the ideology of communism and Trotsky its implementation in the October Bolshevik revolution of Russia in 1917. Trotsky was founder and commander of the red army and his efforts were critical for both the victories of the revolution and the Russian civil war (1918-1923).

The communist revolution liberated Soviet Jews from the ghettos and allowed them to flourish in administrative, academic, and scientific posts in the Soviet state. While Stalin himself was not of Jewish ancestry, much of his cabinet, advisers, and top administrators were of Jewish extraction. Since communism's ideology, implementation, and administration were much carried out by people of Jewish extraction, it was only natural for Stalin to assume the Jewish state would be a communist or socialist one.

If Hitler's war against the Jew was to succeed, then he had to invade the Soviet Union where Jewish dominance in state administration prevailed. Most of the Jewish refugees immigrating into Palestine were from the communist countries of eastern Europe and the Soviet Union, a direct result of the Nazi invasion.

While the Arab population of Palestine was tolerant up to a certain point for small numbers of refugees, the sudden huge influx crossed this reasonable and tolerable threshold. The Arab nations were either British or French colonies. By supporting Israel to cause a successful implementation of socialist state, Stalin hoped to inspire socialist or communist revolutions in the Arab states to overthrow their colonial puppet governments.

Jewish intellectuals in the west were also socialists such as Albert Einstein and Robert Oppenheimer. Einstein was quoted as saying capitalism is economic anarchy. The Rosenberg spy couple who compromised US advantage in nuclear weapons technology to the Soviets and then executed were Jewish. Since many top intellectuals in the west were Jewish and socialist, Stalin, by supporting Israel hoped to at least strengthen the premise of ideological superiority of Marxism over capitalism in western debates, and cause intellectual dissension in western capitalist establishments.

The Bolshevik revolution like the formation of Israel was financed by Wall Street and western Jewish bankers and financiers. Before the Bolshevik revolution most of Russian capital was not Jewish (Gentile) in the ownership of the czar or the church. After the revolution, much of the czar's and the church's gold and other wealth was looted by the Bolsheviks. The western Jewish capital wanted to annihilate the Gentile Russian capital and aristocracy. This was payback after centuries of czarist persecution and pogroms against the Russian Jewish population.
By supporting and recognizing Israel, Stalin wanted to continue this war between the Jewish and Gentile capital as a divide and conquer strategy.

  • 3
    Karl Marx' parents were both of Jewish origin but both converted to Christianity before their wedding, as such he was not rised as jewish even though he would still be considered "jew" by orthodox jews but not really by anyone else. – Bregalad Jun 27 '17 at 18:40
  • @Bregalad Again, we are talking about Jewish tribe and ancestry. Many pragmatic Jews hid their Judaism for life or death choice as in the Spanish inquisition or to just not have to deal with the negative stigma throughout their lives. Marx's parents were the latter. Even in today's Israel many Israeli citizens consider themselves Jewish but have doubts about the existence of God and other fundamental tenants of the Jewish faith. But are totally committed to the Jewish tribe and the Jewish state. – 0tyranny 0poverty Jun 27 '17 at 22:23

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.