Questions tagged [sources]
For questions regarding primary and secondary evidence that allows us to draw conclusions about historical happenings. Use this tag for requests for analysis of specific sources. More general questions on how historians study sources should be tagged with historiography.
107 questions
1
vote
0
answers
122
views
What is the source for Cixi dreaming on the train?
There is a persistent narrative that Cixi (Empress Dowager of the Qing Dynasty) dreamt badly on her first train voyage and therefore banished trains to a place far from Beijing. This was made a film ...
- 2,590
16
votes
1
answer
4k
views
Is this story of John Wesley, a horse, and a bridge true?
I recently heard a story about John Wesley giving way to a stubborn man while on a narrow bridge: in short, Wesley was riding his horse on a bridge, while a man who was known to be a critic of Wesley ...
- 163
14
votes
3
answers
5k
views
Is this a photo of a historical reinactment of an 1868 treaty signing?
I've stumbled up this image in the National Archives describing the 1868 treaty between the Navajo and United States, which was signed when the Navajo were released from Bosque Redondo.
https://...
- 1,087
2
votes
1
answer
210
views
Who claimed Alexander had a hairy heart?
From Avellaneda's Continuation of Don Quixote, chapter 6, p. 34 (circa 1614, translated by Yardley 1784 apparently after the French of Le Sage 1705 but it all seems very confusing). Don Quixote says:
...
- 2,325
35
votes
1
answer
19k
views
Did the Dutch eat their Prime Minister?
According to this article an angry—one might add hungry—Dutch mob feasted on the mutilated remains of their ‘Grand Pensionary’ (i.e. Prime Minister) De Witt and his brother:
There are accounts of ...
- 459
5
votes
1
answer
449
views
Did the Prussian king Friedrich Wilhelm IV. (1795 - 1861) ever write: "Das Volk ist mir zum Kotzen" = "The people makes me sick"?
Where does the Prussian king write "Das Volk ist mir zum Kotzen" = "The people makes me sick," as claimed in 6:26 in Die Revolution von 1848 I musstewissen Geschichte?
The video ...
- 181
6
votes
2
answers
684
views
Is there a standard authority on the textual history of the authors of antiquity?
Given a book coming to us from ancient Greece/Rome (no reason to necessarily limit just to those two, if there's a wider answer), is there a standard way for me to find out how the text came down to ...
- 171
3
votes
1
answer
496
views
What is the original provenance of Lincoln's "of the people, by the people, for the people" and why is Wikipedia so confused?
I was curious about the provenance of Abraham Lincoln's famous Gettysburg Address proclamation regarding government "of the people, by the people, for the people", so I looked it up on ...
- 141
6
votes
2
answers
2k
views
Where can I find Japanese oil production figures through WWII?
I am searching for scientific or statistical sources for data on petroleum production in Japan from 1920 till 1945. I had found some statistics in League of Nations Statistical Bulletins, but there is ...
3
votes
1
answer
532
views
When did Albertus Magnus write 'On Animals'?
When is it most likely that Albertus Magnus finished writing On Animals ?
I can't seem to find any guesses more accurate than "within his lifetime"
user50230
4
votes
1
answer
275
views
How do we know when Nero was born?
If I go onto Wikipedia, I can see an answer of when he was born. But I can't really follow the sources. How do historians know when Nero was born?
- 143
5
votes
0
answers
147
views
How reliable is Herodotus' report on Babylonian sacred harlotry?
I'm looking for confirmation regarding Herodotus' report on sacred harlotry in Babylon:
The foulest Babylonian custom is that which compels every woman of the
land to sit in the temple of Aphrodite ...
- 181
16
votes
2
answers
2k
views
Where was gunpowder invented/ discovered?
There are many people on the internet claiming that India discovered/ invented gunpowder for eg, many of these claims quote Dr. Gustav Oppart (acs.org, and see below). Wikipedia says that gunpowder ...
- 508
2
votes
0
answers
71
views
Did William Ward write "An Address At a Meeting of the Society for Political Information held at the Talbot Inn in Derby, July 16th 1792"?
William Ward (1769–1823) the Baptist missionary assistant to William Carey (1761-1834) was a Derby man and, as a youth at any rate, a radical. He is said to have been the author of "An Address At ...
5
votes
0
answers
154
views
Sources for tracking a ship in the 1840s
I am trying to determine the itinerary of a Danish ship that traveled in the "East Indies" 1841–43. I have its name, captain, departure from and return to Copenhagen.
Additionally, I have ...
- 151
6
votes
2
answers
164
views
Was there an Act of Oblivion in 1686 for those involved in the Monmouth Rebellion 1685?
K.W.H. Howard The Axminster Ecclesiastica 1660-1689 is an annotated reprint of an old Axminster Church record book. In a FN p. 113 it states
“Act of Oblivion 1686. A general amnesty for those ...
9
votes
1
answer
1k
views
When did Lincoln claim that "Vicksburg is the key" to winning the civil war?
In researching the Civil War, I've seen a quote, attributed to Abraham Lincoln, come up several times. The most complete version of the quote I have found comes from this website which gives the quote ...
- 93
4
votes
1
answer
246
views
Where can I find the original Arabic version of bin Laden's 1996 fatwa?
For a paper in my Arabic class, I would like to cite from bin Laden's 1996 fatwa "إعلان الحرب ضد الأمريكيين الذين يحتلون أرض الحرمين الشريفين"
In English: "Declaration of War Against ...
- 43
4
votes
2
answers
865
views
What is the reasoning behind these huge numbers for participants in the Battle of Grunwald 1410?
I was reading about the Battle of Grunwald (Tannenberg) in 1410 during the Polish–Lithuanian–Teutonic War and I found this strange excerpt from current Wikispeedia, (which is based on an old Wikipedia ...
- 435
1
vote
1
answer
870
views
Do historians use Rig Veda as a reliable source of historical event?
Rig veda is the oldest text in Hinduism, it is as old as 1500 BCE.
It contains many historical reference so, do historians use the historical accounts mentioned in the Rig Vedas as reliable sources of ...
- 185
24
votes
3
answers
6k
views
Did the Vikings use horses in battle?
We are currently working on a project which purpose is to depict the Vikings through a digital card video game and we are in the process of researching which cards to put into the game. We have some ...
- 617
4
votes
3
answers
176
views
What was Sir John Mandeville's source regarding Beersheba and its chronology?
After men have crossed this desert on the way to Jerusalem, they come to a city which is called Bersabee [Beersheba] which was once a fine city in habited by Christian men, and still there are some of ...
- 202
3
votes
1
answer
186
views
Are there any contemporary diaries about the Yugoslav Wars?
I struggle to find any, I think about diary, as written by someone who was at the heart of the war, with some proper understanding of the things happening around him, like the "Berlin Diary" ...
- 31
2
votes
1
answer
183
views
Where can I obtain the full "British Statistical Blue Books" of British colonies in Africa?
I'm a poli sci grad student looking to access the full British statistical blue books which catalog statistics for British colonies. Does anyone know where I can obtain access to them, preferably free ...
- 161
6
votes
0
answers
161
views
Are there any sources supporting the claim that Jews were less affected by epidemics?
There is a common thread that Jews historically suffered less from epidemics because of Jewish ritual requirements of cleanliness.
E.g., Wikipedia - Perceived Jewish immunity has 3 weakly supporting ...
- 27k
4
votes
0
answers
751
views
Are there any references of Muhammad's letter to Khosrow II, outside of Islamic historiography?
In Islamic tradition and history it is said that Muhammad sent a letter to Khosrow II, a Sasanid king who was titled king of the kings, inviting him to Islam.
As history is an interactional phenomenon,...
- 183
34
votes
4
answers
4k
views
What is this symbol in a financial record from Wisconsin, USA, in 1860?
I am trying to read some records about wages in Wisconsin in 1860 (the data is from the Social Statistics schedules of the Decennial Census). I cannot read the record from Milton, Rock County, ...
- 449
1
vote
1
answer
167
views
Which ancient cults would cut out the hearts of live animals and offer them as sacrifices?
Which ancient cults would cut out the hearts of live animals and offer them as sacrifices? The Mishnah (Avodah Zarah 2:3) mentions a concept called עורות לבובין which Maimonides and other commentators ...
12
votes
1
answer
1k
views
What is the source of "the three most useless things in the world are the Great Wall, Pyramids, and the Yamato"?
I watched 'Naval Legends: Yamato' yesterday, and it included a phrase that was attributed to the crew of the ship:
"The world's three most useless things are the Chinese Great Wall, Egyptian ...
- 10.8k
2
votes
1
answer
482
views
Are stories passed down from generation to generation considered primary sources? [closed]
I much prepare a lesson differentiating primary/secondary sources, and their functions, and usually this is clear cut, but I ran into a case that challenges me, and also is relevant to the course ...
- 1,087
2
votes
0
answers
103
views
Where does Edmund Burke explain aristocratic eccentricity as a reaction to the influx of non-titled country gentlemen?
I am looking for the source of a notion of Edmund Burke’s that the English aristocracy turned to eccentric behavior in order to distinguish themselves from the “new men” who were acquiring estates in ...
- 121
6
votes
1
answer
454
views
How would an early Medieval German market have looked?
I am trying to find sources on how a medieval German market would have looked. Any artwork (painting, wood carving, wood print) would be perfect, but even just a description would already be great. My ...
1
vote
1
answer
1k
views
Is there footage of Valery Legasov's report at the IAEA Conference in Vienna?
There is a pdf of the report, I could not find any video footage except for brief mentions. However there were lots of cameras there during the report. How to find the full video?
Valery Legasov's ...
- 113
4
votes
2
answers
363
views
How were ancient Indian mathematical texts found to modern scholarship?
Unlike e.g. Greco-Roman or Chinese texts, which were written on relatively durable writing material, most ancient Indian literature was done on palm-leaf manuscripts, which typically don't survive ...
- 51
4
votes
2
answers
2k
views
Are the historical sources from the ancient history trustable?
Are the historical books of Herodot or Polybius or any other historian from ancient history usually correct? Did they add some 'drama' in their books or did they desire to gain favor of those of high ...
- 207
2
votes
2
answers
133
views
Can oral tradition be used as a source in scholarly papers?
If I wanted to write a scholarly paper on, say, Native America wars, would I be able to cite oral traditions as reliable sources of information?
As a made-up example, "the war lasted exactly ...
- 67
9
votes
1
answer
297
views
What is the source for John Adams Sr. writing about Hamilton taking blame for Washington?
I know I read a while ago one of John Adams' writings about how people were generally discontented with Washington during the latter years of his administration, but expressed anger towards Hamilton ...
- 1,666
65
votes
5
answers
136k
views
What is the origin of the lake tank image that has become a meme?
This image, the template for the "Panzer of the Lake" meme, depicts a soldier from an unknown nation looking at what appears to me to definitely be a Panzer. However, no-one seems to know the origins ...
- 1,037
18
votes
1
answer
2k
views
Is there a historical source that might explain why so many countries use 35 as a minimum age for the president / the highest office person?
Reading the list of presidential qualifications by country I have noticed that in many countries the minimum required age is 35 (some countries raise it to 40). I am wondering if there is any ...
- 1,077
3
votes
1
answer
295
views
Where to find Cixi‘s 1865 decree dismissing Prince Gong?
Zhang Rong‘s Cixi biography titled »EMPRESS DOWAGER CIXI: THE CONCUBINE WHO LAUNCHED MODERN CHINA«, Chapter 6, Loc 1365 on kindle claims:
Without the rigid etiquette, she realised, Prince Gong was ...
- 2,590
2
votes
0
answers
40
views
Are there primary source to learn about trade in Southeast Asia circa 1450-1750?
I was wondering if anyone knew any primary sources that will help me learn more about trade in Southeast Asia from 1450-1750. Years are a bit flexible.
I only have two in mind
The Suma Oriental by ...
- 21
2
votes
3
answers
3k
views
Who were the social elites of the European middle ages?
I have recently been reading into the European Middle Ages, where one of the challenges is the limited sources available. I have often seen seen this described as a source bias towards the elite ...
- 105
5
votes
1
answer
186
views
Can anyone render this passage from Lorenzo Valla's original Latin translation of Herodotus into modern text?
Can anyone render this passage from Lorenzo Valla's original Latin translation of Herodotus into modern text? I'm not looking for a translation, rather, I need to have the typographics normalized. ...
- 59
10
votes
1
answer
4k
views
The most awesome army: 80 men left and 81 returned. Is it true?
On this wikipedia page, I read the funny story of the Lichtenstein's army, which should have at least earned the title of the "most friendly army in the world".
I am not a historian, and I have no ...
- 203
4
votes
1
answer
716
views
Did the Picture Post publish the 1857 photo "Two Sepoys of the 31st Native Infantry Who Were Hanged at Lucknow" in 1939?
On the front line of empire, colonials had been developing an increasingly aestheticised response to violence since at least the 1850s, when the Italian-British commercial photographer Felice Beato ...
- 80.8k
3
votes
2
answers
163
views
Where can I find this paper by Jean Buridan?
I'm trying to make a timeline of momentum for my physics class and I keep running across a paper by Jean Buridan called QM XII.9: 73ra. I don't know what any of this means, and I don't know how to ...
- 33
9
votes
1
answer
861
views
What evidence do we have to claim the Ancient Romans kept African grey parrots as pets?
The book Birds: Myth, Lore and Legend by Rachel Warren Chadd and Marianne Taylor states:
[...] The Ancient Romans, who kept both Rose-ringed Parakeets and African Greys (Psittacus erithacus), ..., ...
- 1,537
12
votes
3
answers
3k
views
What is the source for this Leonardo Da Vinci quote?
"Art is the queen of all sciences communicating knowledge to all the generations of the world."
Where exactly does this Leonardo Da Vinci quote come from? Was it part of a larger paragraph - if so ...
- 1,259
9
votes
1
answer
7k
views
Did Napoleon III reserve a special set of aluminum cutlery for special guests?
Slate (2010):
the minor emperor Napoleon III reserved a prized set of aluminum cutlery for special guests at banquets. (Less favored guests used gold knives and forks.)
I see the above claim (or ...
user3521
22
votes
1
answer
752
views
What did Zhang Zuolin say after his train blew up?
Zhang Zuolin was an early 20th century Chinese warlord of Manchuria. He was fatally wounded by the Japanese Army on June 4, 1928, using a bomb laid beneath tracks where his armoured train travelled ...
- 14.5k