Skip to main content
added 337 characters in body
Source Link

I am wondering if B17s ever flew bombing raids against the Japanese mainland, and if so, did they do it before the capture of Okinawa, which was much closer than the previously captured islands like Iwo Jima.

Some links indicating that only B29s were used.

defense.gov

Wikipedia:AirRaidsOnJapan

Iwo Jima - Tokyo (one way): 760 miles/1220 km

Coastal China/Korea to Japan distance is on the order of 800km, but Japan held most, if not all, of the Chinese/Korean coast during the war.

B17-G range - Range: 2,000 mi (3,219 km, 1,738 nmi) with 6,000 lb (2,700 kg) bombload

B29 range - Range: 3,250 mi (5,230 km, 2,820 nmi)

Motivation for this question is a question supposed claim by ChomskyWhy was the USA planning on attacking Japan before Japan's attack on Pearl Harbour? concerning a claim by Chomsky asked on SE Politics that Japan had good reasons to start the war because it was feeling threatened by B-17 bombers.

Furthermore the title of the question implies not only the Japanese perception, but actual US intentions. Which I don't think is based on any kind of objective reality as the B-17 just lacked the range to bomb Japan from any area under US control (or outside the reach of Japan) in 1941.

I am wondering if B17s ever flew bombing raids against the Japanese mainland, and if so, did they do it before the capture of Okinawa, which was much closer than the previously captured islands like Iwo Jima.

Some links indicating that only B29s were used.

defense.gov

Wikipedia:AirRaidsOnJapan

Iwo Jima - Tokyo (one way): 760 miles/1220 km

Coastal China/Korea to Japan distance is on the order of 800km, but Japan held most, if not all, of the Chinese/Korean coast during the war.

B17-G range - Range: 2,000 mi (3,219 km, 1,738 nmi) with 6,000 lb (2,700 kg) bombload

B29 range - Range: 3,250 mi (5,230 km, 2,820 nmi)

Motivation for this question is a supposed claim by Chomsky asked on SE Politics that Japan had good reasons to start the war because it was feeling threatened by B-17 bombers. Which I don't think is based on any kind of objective reality as the B-17 just lacked the range to bomb Japan from any area under US control (or outside the reach of Japan) in 1941.

I am wondering if B17s ever flew bombing raids against the Japanese mainland, and if so, did they do it before the capture of Okinawa, which was much closer than the previously captured islands like Iwo Jima.

Some links indicating that only B29s were used.

defense.gov

Wikipedia:AirRaidsOnJapan

Iwo Jima - Tokyo (one way): 760 miles/1220 km

Coastal China/Korea to Japan distance is on the order of 800km, but Japan held most, if not all, of the Chinese/Korean coast during the war.

B17-G range - Range: 2,000 mi (3,219 km, 1,738 nmi) with 6,000 lb (2,700 kg) bombload

B29 range - Range: 3,250 mi (5,230 km, 2,820 nmi)

Motivation for this question is a question Why was the USA planning on attacking Japan before Japan's attack on Pearl Harbour? concerning a claim by Chomsky asked on SE Politics that Japan had good reasons to start the war because it was feeling threatened by B-17 bombers.

Furthermore the title of the question implies not only the Japanese perception, but actual US intentions. Which I don't think is based on any kind of objective reality as the B-17 just lacked the range to bomb Japan from any area under US control (or outside the reach of Japan) in 1941.

added 299 characters in body
Source Link

I am wondering if B17s ever flew bombing raids against the Japanese mainland, and if so, did they do it before the capture of Okinawa, which was much closer than the previously captured islands like Iwo Jima.

Some links indicating that only B29s were used.

defense.gov

Wikipedia:AirRaidsOnJapan

Iwo Jima - Tokyo (one way): 760 miles/1220 km

Coastal China/Korea to Japan distance is on the order of 800km, but Japan held most, if not all, of the Chinese/Korean coast during the war.

B17-G range - Range: 2,000 mi (3,219 km, 1,738 nmi) with 6,000 lb (2,700 kg) bombload

B29 range - Range: 3,250 mi (5,230 km, 2,820 nmi)

Motivation for this question is a supposed claim by Chomsky asked on SE Politics that Japan had good reasons to start the war because it was feeling threatened by B-17 bombers. Which I don't think is based on any kind of objective reality as the B-17 just lacked the range to bomb Japan from any area under US control (or outside the reach of Japan) in 1941.

I am wondering if B17s ever flew bombing raids against the Japanese mainland, and if so, did they do it before the capture of Okinawa, which was much closer than the previously captured islands like Iwo Jima.

Some links indicating that only B29s were used.

defense.gov

Wikipedia:AirRaidsOnJapan

Iwo Jima - Tokyo (one way): 760 miles/1220 km

Coastal China/Korea to Japan distance is on the order of 800km, but Japan held most, if not all, of the Chinese/Korean coast during the war.

B17-G range - Range: 2,000 mi (3,219 km, 1,738 nmi) with 6,000 lb (2,700 kg) bombload

B29 range - Range: 3,250 mi (5,230 km, 2,820 nmi)

Motivation for this question is a supposed claim by Chomsky.

I am wondering if B17s ever flew bombing raids against the Japanese mainland, and if so, did they do it before the capture of Okinawa, which was much closer than the previously captured islands like Iwo Jima.

Some links indicating that only B29s were used.

defense.gov

Wikipedia:AirRaidsOnJapan

Iwo Jima - Tokyo (one way): 760 miles/1220 km

Coastal China/Korea to Japan distance is on the order of 800km, but Japan held most, if not all, of the Chinese/Korean coast during the war.

B17-G range - Range: 2,000 mi (3,219 km, 1,738 nmi) with 6,000 lb (2,700 kg) bombload

B29 range - Range: 3,250 mi (5,230 km, 2,820 nmi)

Motivation for this question is a supposed claim by Chomsky asked on SE Politics that Japan had good reasons to start the war because it was feeling threatened by B-17 bombers. Which I don't think is based on any kind of objective reality as the B-17 just lacked the range to bomb Japan from any area under US control (or outside the reach of Japan) in 1941.

Tweeted twitter.com/StackHistory/status/1376187339840614403
Became Hot Network Question
added 64 characters in body
Source Link
MCW
  • 34k
  • 12
  • 109
  • 162

I am wondering if B17s ever flew bombing raids against the Japanese mainland, and if so, did they do it before the capture of Okinawa, which was much closer than the previously captured islands like Iwo Jima.

Some links indicating that only B29s were used.

https://www.defense.gov/Explore/Features/story/Article/1995480/strategic-bombing-matured-quickly-during-wwii/

httpsWikipedia://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_raids_on_JapanAirRaidsOnJapan

Iwo Jima - Tokyo (one way): 760 miles/1220 km

Coastal China/Korea to Japan distance is on the order of 800km, but Japan held most, if not all, of the Chinese/Korean coast during the war.

B17-G range - Range: 2,000 mi (3,219 km, 1,738 nmi) with 6,000 lb (2,700 kg) bombload

B29 range - Range: 3,250 mi (5,230 km, 2,820 nmi)

Motivation for this question is a supposed claim by Chomsky.

I am wondering if B17s ever flew bombing raids against the Japanese mainland, and if so, did they do it before the capture of Okinawa, which was much closer than the previously captured islands like Iwo Jima.

Some links indicating that only B29s were used.

https://www.defense.gov/Explore/Features/story/Article/1995480/strategic-bombing-matured-quickly-during-wwii/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_raids_on_Japan

Iwo Jima - Tokyo (one way): 760 miles/1220 km

Coastal China/Korea to Japan distance is on the order of 800km, but Japan held most, if not all, of the Chinese/Korean coast during the war.

B17-G range - Range: 2,000 mi (3,219 km, 1,738 nmi) with 6,000 lb (2,700 kg) bombload

B29 range - Range: 3,250 mi (5,230 km, 2,820 nmi)

Motivation for this question is a supposed claim by Chomsky.

I am wondering if B17s ever flew bombing raids against the Japanese mainland, and if so, did they do it before the capture of Okinawa, which was much closer than the previously captured islands like Iwo Jima.

Some links indicating that only B29s were used.

defense.gov

Wikipedia:AirRaidsOnJapan

Iwo Jima - Tokyo (one way): 760 miles/1220 km

Coastal China/Korea to Japan distance is on the order of 800km, but Japan held most, if not all, of the Chinese/Korean coast during the war.

B17-G range - Range: 2,000 mi (3,219 km, 1,738 nmi) with 6,000 lb (2,700 kg) bombload

B29 range - Range: 3,250 mi (5,230 km, 2,820 nmi)

Motivation for this question is a supposed claim by Chomsky.

added 13 characters in body
Source Link
Loading
added 131 characters in body
Source Link
Loading
Source Link
Loading